Re:Dear Python
by jamesbritt on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @01:11AM
(#1097191)
"Makes sense to me."
Me too.
But: when I see code that refers to first and last, I expect that the first and last elements are special.
When I see integers, it leads me to think that all of the elements are about equally important.
I also find it easier to read the text form rather than the integers; I don't have to look carefully to see if it's 1, 11, 7; code reading goes more smoothly.
Having both forms allows me to express, and parse, intention better.
Re:Dear Python
by stcredzero on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @09:13PM
(#1096866)
That's another demonstration of my point. Many, many people out there in the non-tech world would expect that the first element would have an index of "1". First = "1st" = "#1." On the other hand, we often experience the convenience of pointer arithmetic (or similar) with zero-indexed arrays.
Yet another programmer/techy and ordinary person divide.
If you want something for non-techies, you pick something like Applescript.
0-based indexing is noob friendly because most cs algorithms use it so you can do a straightforward translation. Would it be better to go with 1-based and make this harder for novice programmers? I don't think so.
Makes sense to me.