Re:We brought an antenna to Davos to track private airplanes...
by jgrahamc on Monday January 25, 2016 @08:17AM
(#10966973)
And what they found was... nothing? This is a strange article, you keep thinking they are going to tell you something interesting. And then they don't. For example, they have a map showing that helicopters took the same routes: it's almost as if people are flying to and from the same airports and there's some sort of plan in place for where they fly. Who knew?
Chartering a helicopter flight from Zürich to Davos can cost as much as $10,000. We built our helicopter-tracking rig for under $200.
Is that supposed to be some weird juxtaposition?
Almost feels like this entire article is a justification for them being able to expense the cost of building an ADS-B set up.
Re:We brought an antenna to Davos to track private airplanes...
by brudgers on Monday January 25, 2016 @11:03AM
(#10967871)
I found the story about collecting the data intellectually interesting. [1] That there isn't some earth shattering pseudo-analysis for the sake of link bait is okbyme. Maybe something will pop out of the data or maybe I can simply use it to confirm my own beliefs. Anyway, it reminds me of hacking for the sake of hacking [1] and I appreciate the attention given to the write up: line drawings of helicopters rather than Medium style meme GIF's.
YMMV [1]
[1]: Admittedly, that may be a greater reflection of the low quality of my intellect than the high quality of the article.
Re:We brought an antenna to Davos to track private airplanes...
by nashashmi on Monday January 25, 2016 @09:32AM
(#10967318)
I thought about submitting this article to HN, but I thought it would a waste of everyone's time. There was no "point" of the article. Except for maybe that helicopters are used in Davos.
Re:We brought an antenna to Davos to track private airplanes...
by mynewtb on Monday January 25, 2016 @08:19AM
(#10966980)
Absolutely nothing of relevance? What a sad piece, this should have gone into the drawer or better as a sidenote in some actual reporting to keep others from wasting their time on it.
Re:We brought an antenna to Davos to track private airplanes...
by yanofsky on Monday January 25, 2016 @11:56AM
(#10968251)
I find it interesting because it is the only data that exist that can quantify and contextualize the anecdotal reports of the volume and impact of helicopter use at Davos.
Re:We brought an antenna to Davos to track private airplanes...
by yanofsky on Monday January 25, 2016 @02:05PM
(#10969144)
From the piece:
"We went to all this trouble because there is perennial fascination with the flying habits of the 2,800 Davos delegates. Use of private aircraft, though often wildly overstated, highlights the vast wealth and power that descends upon this small skiing town in the Swiss Alps each year. And their transportation choices are frequently criticized for their environmental impact at a conference that seeks solutions to reducing carbon emissions, among other topics."
Re:We brought an antenna to Davos to track private airplanes...
by Gys on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:10PM
(#10969963)
I was on the island of Sint Maarten for a while. Its a hub in the Caribbean for megayachts and superyachts. You should have a look there around Christmas... Talking about helicopters, wealth and power... And there are many more of those of places and events around the world.
Chartering a helicopter flight from Zürich to Davos can cost as much as $10,000. We built our helicopter-tracking rig for under $200.
Is that supposed to be some weird juxtaposition?
Almost feels like this entire article is a justification for them being able to expense the cost of building an ADS-B set up.
YMMV [1]
[1]: Admittedly, that may be a greater reflection of the low quality of my intellect than the high quality of the article.
- The approximate volume of helicopter traffic that fly into and out of Davos, which was previously unknown
- The approximate number of helicopters that fly into and out of Davos, which was previously unknown
- The exact types of helicopters that were flying around Davos, which was previously unknown
This data also provide a benchmark for future analysis of and reporting on helicopter use patterns at Davos and elsewhere.
"We went to all this trouble because there is perennial fascination with the flying habits of the 2,800 Davos delegates. Use of private aircraft, though often wildly overstated, highlights the vast wealth and power that descends upon this small skiing town in the Swiss Alps each year. And their transportation choices are frequently criticized for their environmental impact at a conference that seeks solutions to reducing carbon emissions, among other topics."