News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Homebrew: OS X’s Missing Package Manager by telemachos on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @04:27PM (#1096182)
Fair enough, but there are two separate questions here:

    1. Where do you want the software?
    2. Are elevated privileges required to put the software where you want?
If you want to load all your software into $HOME/bin, then more power to you and no sudo is required. However, /usr/local serves an important and valid purpose (to provide packages system-wide), and it should not be available without elevated privileges. (By the way, 'not mixed in with system software' is misleading, since OSX ships with an empty /usr/local. Nothing you put in /usr/local mixes with anything.)

Homebrew's official README suggests changing the ownership of /usr/local, and I think that's a terrible idea for multi-user machines. (Having said that, I suppose that many people have single-user machines, and in that case the issue is largely moot.)

Finally, a simple way to put software into your $HOME without ever needing sudo is available in most cases:

    ./configure --prefix=$HOME
Re:Homebrew: OS X’s Missing Package Manager by blasdel on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @04:58PM (#1096284)
And those two separate questions are both ones that no other package manager even bothers to ask!

/usr/local does start off empty on OS X, but it's where every random .pkg you download likes to put stuff. You'll get mixing unless every non-app you install comes from a package manager. On FreeBSD every package that didn't ship in the default install goes there. There's a reason that MacPorts uses /opt/local by default.