I think, at least in the US, we need much stronger consumer advocacy laws, something with teeth that can't be arbitrated down by a group of expensive lawyers.
We'd have to find a balance though, as we are already way too litigious and we'd be stifling innovation out of fear of getting accused of negligence.
> We'd have to find a balance though, as we are already way too litigious and we'd be stifling innovation out of fear of getting accused of negligence.
If we're "way too litigious" to the point of stifling innovation, then I think the problem and solution are in a completely different area than this.
That being said, let the bad actors fail. Let their names get dragged through the mud, let the big companies sober up after a few too many VTech/Mattel/LG style failures that make the headlines. Let them either back out of the market because this shit is hard to keep secure, let them work with someone who can, or let them triple down and figure it out themselves. We're going to see a lot of failures, but we'll be better for it.
I've connected my own devices around my house (securely), use z-wave, and consumer home automation hubs/hardware, as well as some well known stuff like Nest and Amazon Echo. I don't ever want to go back to NOT having these things.
I've accounted for many of the likely failure points by these very well regarded manufacturers and I've firewalled my network very tightly, among many other things. But damn it, I've seen the future and I don't want to go back. It's too nice, too convenient, and adds too much real value.
It's your decision to buy their goods, no one should be preventing anyone from trying to enter the market just because you get the heebie jeebies or don't see the value. Someone else does- or no one else does and they fold up shop.
It is also assumed that these devices have unfettered internet access. Most of them can do HTTPS. Either you allow it or you don't. How many Barbie dolls have been having inappropriate conversations with children that a human would otherwise be arrested for? How many televisions are feeding audio from families back to a company? How long is this data saved? Who has access to it? When must it be destroyed? What legal protections does anyone have against data abuse? What is deemed data abuse? If it turns out I am being spied on, what binding agreement do I have with the manufacturer and seller that will make them feel pain? Are they obligated to give me more than, "We're sorry. Gosh, we're just so darn sorry."
Sorry, no. These devices need to be recycled before they are ever used.
Such laws won't work, however, without a regulatory framework that ensures that -- for example -- click-through EULAs aren't used to lock customers into sleazy "binding arbitration" agreements that sacrifice their rights in return for permission to use an appliance they bought in good faith.
It may be difficult for regulators to keep up with specific technologies, but much tougher consumer rights protection is essential in order to hold negligent manufacturers responsible, because it's cheaper for the cowboy manufacturers to hire a lawyer to draft some dodgy contract boilerplate than it is for them to hire security experts and ship a safe product.