News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unikernels are unfit for production by nickpsecurity on Friday January 22, 2016 @03:27PM (#10955375)
" I'm glad it was written, because I've seen nothing but hype for Unikernels on Hacker News (and in ACM, etc.) for the last 2 years. "

That much is true. I'm countering what I can where it gets overblown. Just part of something going mainstream... crowd effects and so on...

"The only thing I disagree with in the article is debugging vs. restarting. In the old model, where you have a sys admin per box, yes you might want to log in and manually tweak things. In big distributed systems, code should be designed to be restarted (i.e. prefer statelessness). That is your first line of defense, and a very effective one."

Additionally, there's no inherent reason that I see that unikernels are impossible to debug. We can debug everything from live hardware up to apps with existing tooling. So, if unikernels are lacking, it just means they're still young and nobody has adapted proven techniques to debugging them. I imagine the simple ones on simpler HW will make that even easier.

Re:Unikernels are unfit for production by chris_wot on Friday January 22, 2016 @06:21PM (#10956226)
Apparently, you can't Google search for them:

https://twitter.com/bcantrill/status/690580959981211648

#enoughsaid

Re:Unikernels are unfit for production by nickpsecurity on Friday January 22, 2016 @07:04PM (#10956414)
Enough said about what? That there's no current debugging (my claim) or that it's impossible (his)?

"Now, could one implement production debugging tooling in unikernels? In a word, no"

That's a lie: you could implement it. Debugging has been implemented for everything from ASIC's to kernel mode to apps in other categories. Whether unikernel crowd wants to or will is another question. Not looking good there per Google. Him talking like it's impossible shows he has an agenda, though.

I'm guessing he didn't tell everyone to ditch the entire concept of Joylent's offering early on because they were lacking some important features or properties. Just a guess but I'd bet on it.

EDIT: Changing search terms to "debugging" "xen" "guests" got me two results showing foundations are already built. Weak compared to UNIX but there.

https://www.kernel.org/doc/ols/2006/ols2006v2-pages-9-24.pdf

http://www-archive.xenproject.org/files/xensummitboston08/Mu...

Re:Unikernels are unfit for production by chris_wot on Friday January 22, 2016 @08:09PM (#10956686)
Yeah, that's kind of my point :-) I was being a tad sarcastic with the hashtag.
Re:Unikernels are unfit for production by nickpsecurity on Friday January 22, 2016 @08:44PM (#10956800)
Gotcha. Cool.