News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by adrianN on Friday January 22, 2016 @07:45AM (#10952358)
I think "inflammation" is the modern day's "bad humors". We don't really understand the relationship between inflammation and illness and yet inflammation get's sold to the public as an important cause. Unfortunately, anti-inflammatory drugs don't improve outcomes for heart disease or Alzheimer's, even though inflammation is somehow implicated.

So mucking about with worms or other parasites to give the immune system something to do is most likely not a good idea until we better understand the underlying mechanisms.

Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by brianwawok on Friday January 22, 2016 @08:59AM (#10952692)
Sports medicine has always been a bit more pragmatic than other branches of medicine. "We have no idea how this works, but it makes people run/swim faster, so let's do it!"

I think a lot of work 10 or 20 years ago went into reducing inflammation. Less inflammation = could train again the next day! Pound down that Advil at the end of your workout so you are ready to go!

Over the last few years, it seems more and more people are saying "The inflammation process is what makes your body stronger - you can't stop it without losing the benefits!"

On the other hand, I do still see inflammation stopping treatments around. i.e. football players after a game getting into basically a freezer for 15 seconds to reduce muscle inflammation. Possibly the logic there is that they are already trained and not looking to get "stronger", just recover from the days damage as fast as possible to get ready for the next game.

Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by grhino on Friday January 22, 2016 @09:42AM (#10952930)
I've heard that the goal for many football players is not long term health but to get out there and play while the opportunity is there. Reducing inflammation works so that you feel like you can go out and play again without adequate recovery. When the average football player has only a few months for a few years to make their mark, playing through injury or pain is the goal rather than the proper recovery.
Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by brianwawok on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:02AM (#10953458)
Which then makes sense for them in a way, but makes treating inflammation something that maybe isn't as important for the general population (as most of us are hopefully in it for the long haul)
Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by marincounty on Friday January 22, 2016 @12:05PM (#10953948)
Sports medicine seems to forget about the placebo effect.

I've seen players, weekend warriors, even former amateur athletes trying to improve injury recovery times/performance with procedures, folklore, gadgets, or just "This is what my coach said".

I believe we need to get the strong science into sports medicine. And when pointed to studies, they are like studies done in too many psychology studies--"The study compared twenty athletes to blah, and no follow up with larger objective studies.

The athlete is the perfect candidate for placebo cures, in so many cases.

Sports medicine seems to hurt a lot of athletes with the whole, "Hay--it works!". Yea, and it kills, and shortens life spans in athletes(professional) too?"

I don't want to argue, but I believe Lance Armstrong won most of those wins with the placebo effect.

Yea--scream all you want. Lance didn't come across as that knowledgable. He belived everything those doctors were telling him.

I'll never forget something his Italian doctor said when he was being roasted over all the drugs. I won't get the quote right, but it was after all the villagers/authorities busted the two of them. Lance one one race without anything in his system. He might have had blood transfusions? It doesn't matter, his doctor said, "Lance won on the placebo effect! Probally all along?"

Not one reporter asked what the placebo effect was. I have a weird feeling most of those drugs were hampering his performance. But the super powers of that placebo effect were magic?

Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by crpatino on Friday January 22, 2016 @08:13PM (#10956700)
> I believe we need to get the strong science into sports medicine.

Professional sports already bring on board the best (applied) science that money can buy. The approach is practical because there are billions of dollars on the line. If that is not good enough for you uppity sense of scientific purity, too bad. When you own a team, you'll be free to do as you please with your own money (just don't complain if your team is beaten by all the others that do not share your scientific sensitivities).

Professional athletes and their coaches will not stop doing what is well known to work just because a bunch of nerds have a quasi-religious taboo against the "placebo effect".

Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by brianwawok on Friday January 22, 2016 @02:56PM (#10955164)
> Sports medicine seems to forget about the placebo effect.

Well, people who make gadgets are well aware of it - and use it to make a LOT of money :)

On the other hand, sports performance is 50% mental. If wearing one green sock and one red socks makes you think you are faster, then why not? You may really be faster.

I am not sure I would want a FDA Like body over sports gadgets. * These sunglasses have NOT been shown in blind studies to make you run 5% faster. Any statements along those lines are by paid actors.

Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by graeme on Friday January 22, 2016 @01:15PM (#10954492)
Is that the same case? It seems like the sports coaches are reducing acute inflammation, for a specific, short term performance goal. With probable long run damage.

Whereas the information people warn against generally is chronic inflammation. The kind that wouldn't occur in a healthy person. But the kind that does occur, and is measurable, in someone who eats poorly, doesn't exercise, sleeps inadequately, and is stressed. I believe C-reactive protein is the main measure.

That doesn't mean inflammation is the cause of the problems associated with those lifestyle problems. I'm sure that's a complicated question - targeting it specifically might be pointless if the underlying causes remain. Just noting that the inflammation you're talking about is a different variety.

Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by wnevets on Friday January 22, 2016 @10:56AM (#10953416)
>Sports medicine has always been a bit more pragmatic than other branches of medicine. "We have no idea how this works, but it makes people run/swim faster, so let's do it!"

Doesn't sports medicine still blame lactic acid as the cause of muscle fatigue?

http://www.details.com/story/lactic-acid-workout

Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by brianwawok on Friday January 22, 2016 @11:02AM (#10953453)
Ya some do, although it seems that it is starting to turn.

Remember - I said sports medicine was pragmatic not correct ;) While muscles are being used heavily, a ton of lactic acid is made faster than it can be recycled by the body. So no it's not causing fatigue there is a high correlation between lactic acid and muscles being fatigued. Lactic threshold is still a very interesting concept, the point at which you recycle lactic acid at the same speed as it is created. What the heck lactic acid does is maybe less important to sports performance...

Re:If being too clean makes us sick, why isn’t getting dirty... by Spooky23 on Friday January 22, 2016 @02:37PM (#10955052)
Not really, some members of the public don't understand it.

Inflammation is a symptom, and chronic inflammation leaves you vulnerable to other problems. It's also pretty easy to measure.

As an example, when I was struggling with back problems, at one point my sed rate was over 90mm/hr (ie. really bad). It was 3 about 3-4 years prior, and 25 about 6 months prior to my spinal fusion. (I was 25 at the time) Drawing the conclusion "inflammation caused back problems" is wrong. Using the inflammation measurement to say "things are getting worse" as part of an overall assessment of my condition is a sensible conclusion.