Fair enough. You might even be right. Even if one were to assume that you are, however, why does it follow that those involved should be happy with their fate as a stepping stone for society? That their complaints are nothing but "childish whining"?
Furthermore, the fact that an action creates winners and losers is far less open to interpretation than its ultimate connection to the progression (or regression) of society. If you substitute faith in one system for faith in another then the same argument you made earlier has been made in a million other contexts to defend acts that you would consider unconscionable. In this context "It's for the best, honest!" is a weak argument regardless of how convinced you are that your model of ultimate benefit/detriment to society is correct.
My post was responding to the fact that increased immigration (of high tech or white collar, both) helps people in general by increased prosperity (nothing in this post was about an emotional outburst of the conditions and welfare of immigrants).
You respond by talking a non-sequitur about a bubble. It doesn't make any sense.
Funny thing is, what you wrote rhetorically is exactly what happens in a crash.
As a consumer you don't care whether your salary is $100K or $50K, what matters is what you can buy from your salary. If you can buy a home on mortgage on $50K salary and save for your kid's education, but can barely pay rent and groceries on $100K then the $50K Salary is higher 'real salary' (albeit a lower 'nominal salary').
Any recession is only cleared when real wages fall faster than the real prices of the goods (because only then businesses can be profitable again).
According to free market economists, let wages and goods of prices fall. This will eventually clear the market.
According to non-free market economists (which includes Keynesians and monetarists) increasing the money supply is the solution because it lowers the real wages (albeit keeping the nominal wage high). So at the end of a recession you still make same salary as you did at the start of the recession, but you can afford fewer goods now. This ALSO clears out the market and businesses become profitable again.
Introduction of educated immigration labor would actually result in faster recovery (just like lowering of interest rates would make businesses more profitable).