"I don't do X because I think it's bad - let's tax/shame/incarcerate anybody who does X, because they're too stupid to realize how bad X is! Think of the children!!!"
and
"I can't believe they're taxing Y! I've been doing Y for years, and it's my business. It's a 'free' country!"
When they stop doing so, of course. It depends on how much you value different kinds of personal freedom.
I for example believe that it would be reasonable to tax unhealthy food more than healthy food and have people who are overweight pay more for their health insurance. But I don't think that tracking everyone's movement outweighs potential benefits from taxing lack of physical activity.
Furthermore, there are medical conditions--and even treatments for medical conditions--that can cause obesity that have nothing to do with a person's diet. Should the people suffering from these situations be charged more for their health insurance?
Here's a real-world example:
A friend of mine's wife was, at the time they discovered she was pregnant, diagnosed with leukemia. It has been the most awful thing I've witnessed in some time. A mid-five-foot woman, who probably barely weighed 120 pounds, after months of different treatments, wound up with a host of medical complications, then further treatments. This all wound up causing her to gain what looked like probably 100+ pounds. Last year, they paid over $18K in out-of-pocket medical expenses.
It seems unconscionable to me to advocate my friend and his wife should have to pay more for health insurance because she's now technically obese. They can already barely survive (she cannot work, and he spent 5 months unemployed last year).
Bottom line: very few things are simply black-and-white. There are so many shades of gray. The real world is full of myriad complications and counterexamples that ought to help us realize we can't just draw simplistic lines in the sand based on silly, poorly conceived premises. Oh sure, it sounds good when the idea pops in your head, especially when it doesn't affect you--always because your conception doesn't ever include you. But it's bound, like all things, to come down with undeserved and unbalanced harshness on somebody. And that leads to having to probe whether or not these ideas are just and fair. Oftentimes, they are not.
While there has been plenty of disagreement in nutrition science, there's also a lot of agreement. It's pretty well established that highly processed foods that are loaded with sugar, salt and fat are less healthy than fresh vegetables. When the science changes, laws can also change, and we don't have to have laws that are so specific as to make the "perfect" diet free and any other diet prohibitively expensive.
Examples like your friend that have a hard time controlling their calorie intake due to medical complications are pretty rare. But indeed, as you say, things are not black and white, which is why, in general, laws are fairly complex and it needs lawyers to understand them. It's not like the current tax code doesn't have any special cases for exceptional circumstances. But figuring out all the special cases needed for a tax code that rewards healthy behaviour is probably way out of scope for a HN comment thread.
I don't see cigarettes as a personal freedom issue. As long as you find people insensitive enough to smoke in public areas and force those of us that don't smoke to breathe their toxic air, cigarettes should be taxed just like other pollutants are. Taxes are one of the few ways that capitalism has of dealing with externalities.
I feel the same way about cars. Your statement fits perfectly:
As long as you find people insensitive enough to drive/idle in public areas and force those of us that don't to breathe their toxic air, cars should be taxed just like other pollutants are.
And that's a slippery slope. What makes you think the line can't actually be drawn. I'm all for personal freedom generally though, but I think adjusting the position of the line to find it's optimal balance is a fine alternative to erasing it altogether.
Agreed. I hate using these terms, but the "progressive liberal agenda" that wants to make "HealthCare Free For All" will make your health choices everyone's business.
I'm not paying for your triple bypass surgery, therefor red meat is going to be taxed higher. Etc...etc... Carry it all out to it's logical conclusion and you'll see that soon enough personal freedom won't mean much in a collectivist society and there will be no line to draw.
Then they converge in the middle, and methodically slaughter any chance at rationally examining the science, with their sharp blades made from laminated dollar bills.
Politics and science do not mix well. Some may not like that other people eat beef steaks. Others may not like enriched white flour or high fructose corn syrup. Some people might not like genetically modified whatevers, or artificial hormone treated this-and-thats. But I don't want my diet to be constrained on all sides by FUD and scaremongering.
Besides that, I don't believe that cigarettes are taxed heavily as a means to benefit the public health. I believe that they are taxed heavily because nicotine addicts will just pay that much for a fix. The supposed health benefit just makes it easier for other people to ignore that a consumer product is being selectively taxed at a scandalously high rate.
Exactly this. Cigarettes aren't being taxed out of any semblance of altruistic care for public health--that altruistic care is arguably borne out in anti-smoking laws in public places. The taxes, however, are simply a shakedown, like every other type of "sin tax" levied to collect money from people who enjoy a thing that cannot or will not be universally defended as something that is "okay" to enjoy.
There is no inherent reason why anyone's health choices need to be anyone else's business if we were to suddenly awake and find ourselves delighted by the existence of universal public healthcare. We decide as a society what is up for discussion. We can actually agree to respect everyone's personal freedom to make their own choices, and reject allowing John's choice to eat a steak now and again to be any of Mary's business. After all, we're going to do the same when we tell John he has to shut the fuck up about Mary's choice to consult with her physician about an abortion. And, of course, we'll agree that neither John nor Mary gets to say anything about Phil's third visit to rehab this year.
Instead, we steer the national discussion away from finger-pointing, privacy-invading, witch-hunting bullshit, and focus it toward elevating a national ideal of living healthy, responsible, active lives. Sure, there are going to be choices made that don't fit the ideal, but we prize personal freedom. We equally protect everyone. We equally care for everyone. Why? Because there are people who eat red meat who never have triple-bypass surgery; people who smoke who never die of smoking complications; people who drink who never have alcohol-related health issues; people who never eat meat who wind up with some other health issue. We can take care of each other because we want to create and inhabit a great society.
Sure, it may be a pipe dream we never see realized in our own lifetimes. But it ought not be so difficult to imagine alternatives, recognize some valuable principles, and advocate for realizing those principles because they inherently respect and value people as co-citizens in a shared society.
It is lobbying by the alcohol and tobacco industry that has kept these respective products as socially acceptable, in spite of the harm caused by smoking, drunk driving, and alcoholism, etc. My view on this matter is pragmatic and impure: society lead by its influencers decides the evil du jour. Sometimes they make good choices and sometimes poor. The world didn't collapse when cigarette taxes started to increase, the tobacco makers didn't die as a result of the lawsuits, and everyone moved on to e-cigarettes.
[1] https://theintercept.com/2016/01/06/wasserman-schultz-fueled...
The insurance industry wants to not have to pay for your care. The government wants you to not be sick.
Somewhere around harmful (not just unhealthy) addictive substances.
(Philosophical(?) question: is it personal freedom when you're addicted?)
If you want the public to make healthier choices, do it the right way, with scaremongering and emotional rhetoric. Or rational argument, I guess, if you're some kind of quixotic masochist.~
If addiction is your criterion, just pick one of the things you classify as "just unhealthy", and type "X addiction" into google :)
Not really, I used to smoke but I quit.
That's a straw man, and also quite patronizing. You can hold a rational ethical position without buying into the mythology of Marlboro man. The question still stands: if you accept that health benefits can outweigh personal freedom, where do you draw the line?