News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by w1ntermute on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:49AM (#10945508)
> It long since stopped being about innovation and disrupting markets and became mostly about shuffling piles of imaginary units around so a select few could get rich.

As someone mentioned on another thread a day or two ago, just look at the latest YC batches, particularly the IT companies. They're largely "X for Y" sorts of companies that already have significant traction. It's unlikely that the Airbnb founders would be able to get into YC in 2016.

> Sadly the pawns in this whole game will be all the employees holding options that are soon to be worthless... and who were convinced to take those options in exchange for taking a proper cash salary.

And on the other side, once the bubble bursts and the options are exposed as worthless at many of these companies, it's going to be much harder for startups to recruit employees with equity compensation, which will only make it more difficult to control burn rates.

Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by kolbe on Thursday January 21, 2016 @10:49AM (#10945974)
I'm trying to coin the term "portmanco" for these companies. Just like a portmanteau in linguistics simply mashes two words together, a portmanco just mashes two familiar companies together and calls it a new one.
Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by Terr_ on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:23AM (#10946237)
> mashes two familiar companies together and calls it a new one.

Hasn't that always been what "merger" meant? :p

Edit: My joke is that corporations have been making dumb amalgamations for many many years now. Anybody remember "Mr. Sparkle" from The Simpsons, where two companies in fish vs. heavy-industries combined to sell detergent? That was amusingly-relatable even when it came out 18 years ago.

Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by jstanley on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:29AM (#10946285)
AirBnB for Dogs isn't a merger between AirBnB and dogs.
Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by Terr_ on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:34AM (#10946322)
Wait, I thought he said two companies merged, not a company plus an arbitrary concept. (Or is there really a company just named "Dogs" involved in canines?)
Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by calpaterson on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:44AM (#10946395)
Sorry, I down-voted you before I understood your joke. :(
Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by kolbe on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:55AM (#10946490)
I'm actually still confused about whether it's a joke or if the guy is making a pedantic criticism of my choice of words.
Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by yourapostasy on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:18PM (#10946662)
That's disturbingly like what I hear film industry people complaining about for nigh-on decades now. Script pitches are too commonly derivatives starting out with "like X [already super-successful film], but|with|and|except|etc. Y [another successful film]".

The general explanation for this phenomena that I've read bandied about (but have no idea of its veracity as I'm just an industry outsider): financing films has gotten so expensive and risky, that only proven models of making money are commonly given green lights. It's considered innovation at the financial level to mix-and-match proven models, because that's all the risk that is willing to be absorbed. What the purchasing side actually wants is too opaque/non-linear/unpredictable/take-your-pick-of-explanation for the big name finance people to consistently figure out what really is innovative. That's probably why YC attracts a lot of attention from the big names, because they hold out the promise of piercing that veil.

Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by kolbe on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:50PM (#10946902)
I'll be a little bit more cynical than you, and give you my opinion. In the movie industry[1], just like with the start-up industry, we see these types of behaviors pop up when the company or the art stops being the object of the creators affections, but instead it's the money or power. It's the "MBA" attitude that gets railed against on HN, where the only reason these people participate is to cash out, or in some cases with people who are already rich, they want to feel like they're important.

Now, these people are plenty smart. They usually have gotten great educations and whatnot, but they lack the drive to be motivated by a love of doing this great thing, rather than accumulating some money. Some of the greatest creations in tech were not motivated by money at all. When a great film maker goes to bed or on vacation, he's sometimes kept awake with ideas on how to make a better film or pondering a new concept. He takes no real vacations, because he loves his art so much that he never even wants to escape it. The money-driven type doesn't. When they go on vacation, they escape. And professionally, they tend take the easiest path to their destination. And the easiest path to cashing out is to look at how other people became successful, and make a small deviation from their path then copy or exploit rent seeking advantages or be unethical.

I think that's where all these portmancos come from. It's really really easy to look at existing business models, and come up with a way to blend them into new company.

[1] I'll assume everything you just told me is correct

Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by gutnor on Thursday January 21, 2016 @11:32AM (#10946309)
> it's going to be much harder for startups to recruit employees with equity compensation,

Ageism in the valley is probably caused in part by that. Older developers have already been burnt in 2000 and are less willing to try another round (I have known a few of the virtual millionaire) and even those that have been working through the crisis are going to have a cautious approach. So that tilt the balance even more toward the younger developer working in hot startup and it becomes easy for their owner to mistake correlation for causation and assume older developer simply don't have what it takes.

I remember raising my eyebrows when my grand father was skeptical of banks and government guarantees. I have now lived through banks failing, government taking money off private account, ... Today I wouldn't be so dismissive of his concerns. So easy to mistake wisdom for old age stubbornness when you only have had an uneventful short existence.

Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by jpmattia on Thursday January 21, 2016 @10:34AM (#10945842)
> and the options are exposed as worthless at many of these companies, it's going to be much harder for startups to recruit employees with equity compensation, which will only make it more difficult to control burn rates.

As someone who lived through TechBubble v1: People said exactly the same thing back then. There's always a new batch of graduates with dollar signs in their eyes who believe "it's different this time".

Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by donkeyd on Thursday January 21, 2016 @09:57AM (#10945568)
Which seems like a good thing to me, because then maybe, just maybe, startups with steady revenue growth will get funded again.
Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by w1ntermute on Thursday January 21, 2016 @10:02AM (#10945610)
Exactly - good entrepreneurs/companies can raise money and hire employees in any capital climate. It's the companies that lack basic building blocks, like a mission that resonates with employees on a non-financial level and sustainable sources of revenue, that will go under.

Square is a great example of a company that people joined for all the wrong reasons. Not only are they incredibly unfocused when it comes to their mission, products and customer base, but the people joining it seemed to be doing so out of a mercenary instinct triggered by an expectation that Jack's second company would of course be a hit.

Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by scurvy on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:24PM (#10946713)
Just like Andreesen's second company was destined to be a hit. Ex Loudclouder here. I'd say 90% of us were there for that reason.
Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by w1ntermute on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:36PM (#10946806)
And Andreessen left Loudcloud in 2005, well before the final Opsware exit, to found his third company Ning (which he never talks about), which ate $134M in funding, only to be acquired for $150M.

If you actually look at what Andreessen did at Netscape, he was little more than the pawn of Jim Barksdale and Jim Clark, who trotted him out as the "boy genius" every time they needed to do some PR or developer/community outreach. The vast majority of the code was written by the far better software engineers than Andreessen who joined the founding team (Lou Montulli, Jamie Zawinski, Ramanathan Guha, Aleksandar Totic, and more).

Other than that, I'm not even sure why Clark approached Andreessen to co-found Netscape. There were multiple people who worked on NCSA Mosaic, which was itself based on open standards (and the source could be obtained). And Andreessen didn't really believe in its commercial potential at first - he moved to SV to work at Enterprise Integration Technologies, only to quit his job after a few months, when Clark emailed him.

Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by erroneousfunk on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:07PM (#10946572)
> it's going to be much harder for startups to recruit employees with equity compensation

Great. The employees who don't want to, or can't accept potentially risky future compensation for their work, no matter what the reasons, shouldn't have to. That's why investors exist. They take on the risk, you get to pay employees actual money, win/win.

In addition, equity is just as much a "burnable resource" as money is. Those percents add up. If you're using it as an infinitely-growing imaginary carrot because you find that your runway is getting shorter and shorter as the months go by... well, that's probably not a good sign.

Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by wuschel on Thursday January 21, 2016 @10:18AM (#10945715)
I guess there is just a limited solution space for the current problems, and many possible points have been farmed at a certain point of time. Until legislative or technologic changes come in, the eco-system will go more and more into bubble mode.
Re:90% of the billion dollar unicorn startups are in trouble by wuschel on Thursday January 21, 2016 @12:35PM (#10946804)
Please explain the downvotes. Sure, the comment was a quick shot comment about 'X for Y' ventures, but I do indeed guess that many current IT unicorns are not straying so much into bleeding edge technology, but are following a market grab/lockdown strategy on platforms (www/mobile) that are fairly well developed. And I do not want to claim that any of those approaches are bad - people seem to speculate that they can make a lot of money from them.