News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HTT Breaks Ground to Make Hyperloop a Reality by Animats on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:40PM (#10941584)
I like their proposal to close off the ports of San Francisco, Oakland, Stockton, Richmond, and Redwood City so they can run their pipe across the Golden Gate just above sea level.[1]

The tube size seems to be increasing, with proposals now up to narrow-body airliner dimensions. That's probably necessary, but it makes it harder to put tubes in freeway medians.

Nobody seems to have a good solution to emergency escape. There's an assumption that vehicles can be pushed or driven to the next station. That's probably not good enough. Experience with subways and Eurotunnel indicates the need for escape systems. Emergency exits at the ends of cars, escape stations from the tubes, and emergency repressurization systems for the tubes will probably be necessary. Airlock doors across the tube will be needed so you can repressurize a section rapidly, without waiting to repressurize hundreds of miles of tube. That's all possible, but it adds cost. Remember, the whole point of this is that it's supposed to be much cheaper than maglev, because the tube is cheap and dumb.

This is a classic problem with monorails, too. Look at pictures of fictional monorails[2] vs pictures of real ones.[3] The real ones have bigger and heavier track. Single track sections usually have walkways, while double track sections can use a rescue train on a parallel track. Here's a list of monorail fires and evacuations.[4] Remember that Hyperloop cars are powered by lithium batteries.

At least HTT is trying to build a closed loop. Musk's prototype is just a straight run. Straight is easy for this; it's turns that are hard. Turn radius is the big constraint on high speed anything - route planning and land acquisition are very tough for large turn radii. That's why the Northeast Corridor rail system runs so slowly.

Maybe people will be more tolerant of high-G turns if roller coaster videos are played inside.

The Hyperloop system is probably buildable. It's the low-cost claim that may not hold up.

[1] http://techcrunch.com/2016/01/19/hyperloop-transportation-te... [2] http://www.transfuture.net/transart/albums/userpics/10002/ci... [3] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/3e/Tokyo_Mo... [4] http://www.monorails.org/tMspages/KimEd3.html

There are no comments on this comment yet.