News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by staunch on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @03:48PM (#10941216)
YC only helps ~3% of the startups that request help and now they're discouraging people from seeking help elsewhere.

There's gotta be a better way of handling this.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by paul on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:29PM (#10941510)
I agree. This is part of the reason that we are making more of our advice freely available online (e.g. http://startupclass.samaltman.com/ and http://playbook.samaltman.com/).

The problem with a bad accelerator is that they can actually harm your company with bad advice and unnecessary distractions.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by danieltillett on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:06PM (#10941743)
Paul when you are building a startup are there any necessary distractions (HN excluded).

You really should name and shame the bad accelerators. I know no one likes to be negative, but if there are accelerators out there messing up companies and leading founders astray then it would be best to make this information public. You will take some heat for doing this, but you guys should be able to handle it.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by paul on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:22PM (#10941838)
There are hundreds of accelerators with more appearing all of the time (plus significant management turnover in many of the programs). Evaluating them all would be a full-time job for several people. I'd rather put that effort into finding more ways to help more startups.
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by danieltillett on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:54PM (#10942030)
I would hope the fact that a problem is hard is not a reason to not do it :)

More seriously, it depends on how serious the bad accelerator problem is and you guys are one of the few that have the data on this. If it is a minor problem then I agree there are better ways to help, but if it is a major problem then it needs to be addressed.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by tptacek on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:07PM (#10942127)
Wouldn't it be super weird for the leading accelerator to start formally rating its competitors? There's a difference between having good data and being in a position to help people by publishing it.
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by danieltillett on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:32PM (#10942268)
It certainly would be weird given SV has never worked like this, but it would be incredibly powerful in effecting change.

Actually just an acknowledgement of the level of the problem with no names attached would be highly useful to the community. Very few people have access to this data and YC is one. The fact that Sam wrote about this makes me suspect that it is a major problem.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by jholman on Thursday January 21, 2016 @03:14AM (#10944026)
Wouldn't it be super weird for the leading experts in <professional field> to start formally rating their competitors, i.e. other more-junior professionals in that field?

Y'know, the way it's done by all professions worthy of the name?

No, it would not be weird at all, and more importantly, it'd be good for consumers of that industry.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by tptacek on Thursday January 21, 2016 @07:50AM (#10944845)
What's an example of a profession where the leading firm publishes ratings of all its competitors?
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by jholman on Friday January 22, 2016 @04:29PM (#10955711)
I cannot think of an example exactly like that. But in many professions, senior members are the ones who certify junior members. Law, medicine, all the reputable parts of finance.

I mean, to make my actual argument, instead of just alluding to it, it seems to me that:

1) it's good for consumers of an industry to have ratings of the providers in that industry

2) I can think of three sources for such ratings: crowd-sourced ex-customer ratings, ratings by a purported expert-at-rating, ratings by peers. I think these each have their merits.

3) If ratings-by-peers is indeed useful, then in a given industry, it has to start somewhere.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by tedmiston on Friday January 22, 2016 @06:50AM (#10952174)
I think you can't just give an accelerator the binary label of good/bad.

Sometimes different alumni have very different experiences. Sometimes an accelerator's niche is very relevant to one company's problem but not another's. As Sam's advice said -- it's more useful to qualitatively talk to someone you know (and also trust, or at least consider credible) to evaluate their opinions on the accelerator. There are too many unique factors.

Obviously, this is hard for a new-ish (pre-) accelerator, so one heuristic I've used instead is to review the experience of the accelerators' founders and mentor network. It's a start.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by daurnimator on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @11:03PM (#10943282)
That doesn't help with the networking aspect though; which is probably the most important part.
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by nostrademons on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:35PM (#10941551)
I don't think they're discouraging people from seeking help elsewhere so much as saying that if you get help elsewhere, don't also expect help from YC unless your numbers are really, really good.

In other words, if you're going to go with another accelerator, commit to that program and decide that you're going to build a real business off it. It worked for both SendGrid and Digital Ocean. Don't expect that you'll be able to bounce between programs and accept help from everyone, because if you need that much help, it starts looking like you really don't have your shit together as a founder.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by Alex3917 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:08PM (#10941366)
They're not discouraging people from seeking help elsewhere, they're just saying that going through any accelerator starts the clock on your company.
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by krschultz on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:14PM (#10941411)
What happens if you apply to YC and another accelerator and need to respond to the other accelerator while you are waiting to hear back from YC?
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by _sentient on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @06:14PM (#10942183)
Good accelerators don't make exploding offers.

People who make exploding offers are not just bad, they're also acutely aware of that fact, thus the manufactured scarcity.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by beambot on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @08:12PM (#10942701)
I don't know. I think a reasonable person could construe the YC statement [1] as manufactured scarcity too, even if YC makes the statement for sound reasons. It could be construed as a pre-exploding offer (or threat).

Not that I agree with that interpretation; I think YC's viewpoint makes a lot of sense -- especially if it is a proven negative indicator of success.

[1] "If you apply to other accelerators, then we'll be more critical of you."

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by _sentient on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @09:31PM (#10942973)
I think it's clear that's not the intention here. The message is basically "the clock starts ticking with funding, so expect to meet a higher bar".

This is similar to the notion that a startup can "sell the dream" up until the point where they have revenue, after which they're no longer selling dreams, they're selling the trend.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by RickHull on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @07:59PM (#10942649)
> What happens if ...

Make a decision, and then make the most of that decision. Sam is not saying it's bad to do other accelerators. However, for very natural reasons, graduates of other accelerators have more expected of them. Likewise, I doubt YC would accept their own graduates for another round.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by sama on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:40PM (#10941586)
We don't want to do that; however, I think sometimes when people think they're getting help they're actually getting hurt.

One of our goals is to release as much advice as we can for free for anyone.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by rachellaw on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:02PM (#10941721)
one of the key reasons why people join accelerators is for network and connections though, not just advice.

Without that conversations, that sounding board, all that written advice just makes another investopedia/venturehacks guidebook. Most startup founders already do the google legwork and required readings. It's great, but not the main reason why people would apply for YC.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by danieltillett on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:10PM (#10941382)
Yes stop worrying about YC and get on with building your business.
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by mikeryan on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:47PM (#10941624)
I think this sounds great in a hand wavy way but most folks don't have unlimited time and funds to do this and need to raise money in order to build their business So worrying about YC / other accelerator /angel funding is not mutually exclusive of "building your business"
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by danieltillett on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:01PM (#10941715)
Well as someone who has built a (moderately) successful startup without any outside funding or acceleration I have a different perspective on this.

While I do think YC provides a lot of value to their alumni, people can get fixated on the process of raising funds and not building their business. Build a great business making real money and you won’t need funding.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by mikeryan on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:27PM (#10941872)
Look I run a (moderately) successful services firm that's been completely bootstrapped as well ;-)

I totally get it, but for every github and Atlassian there's also a Facebook and Snapchat or a hardware startup (wish I could think of one now...) where outside funding is essential.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by danieltillett on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:48PM (#10941982)
I think the key here is don’t try and build a Snapchat or Facebook unless you are an insider. Build a business that works first and once you have the experience, skill, and most importantly contacts, then build a VC-only business if you really want to.
Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by ogreveins on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @05:04PM (#10941733)
It makes sense to become profitable more quickly then. Github was profitable nearly from the get go. So was Atlassian. There's also that guy who lived in japan and made flash cards for teachers. There's also the guy who made You Need A Budget with just an excel spreadsheet and some charisma.

If your business idea is too big to make without large (seed investment size) amounts of funds then you should pick something else or get a job and slowly build it with your own income.

Suck it up.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by staunch on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @08:31PM (#10942778)
This is actually the conventional wisdom despite nearly all of the evidence being against it.

You can name the few startups that have done what you're recommending, but every other (high growth) startup did it the way you're knocking.

A great many people try to create startups while maintaining day jobs. You don't hear about those ones, ever.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by danieltillett on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @09:13PM (#10942919)
Sure the startups that make the most noise are typical VC backed businesses. The ones you don’t hear about are the ones where the founders control 100% of the business, are in highly profitable niches, and where they make a few million a year in profit which they get to keep.

These type of businesses get very little press, but they are very good to own and run - I of course know nothing about them :)

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by tedmiston on Friday January 22, 2016 @07:26AM (#10952290)
PlentyOfFish is a good example of this. http://www.businessinsider.com/how-markus-frind-bootstrapped...

Though by the traditional silicon valley definition of startup, the ones like you describe can be labeled something like lifestyle businesses, solopreneur ventures, etc. I think people like Chris Guillebeau (The $100 Startup), Jason Fried / DHH (blogs and books), and Marco Ament are successful people to read that are also good examples of starting businesses this way. Maybe even Tim Ferriss (4HWW).

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by ProAm on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:31PM (#10941522)
Sort of reminds me of the late night talk shows in America. They frequently said, "if you're going to do Leno, you can't go on Letterman, if you do you're never invited back" and vice-versa*

* = Unless you are an A-list celebrity (or Unicorn) in which case we'll take you no matter what.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by smileysteve on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @07:08PM (#10942440)
I think that you're stretching for that. There are a number reason to suspect that a second accelerator will be less effective that the first:

* You already got advice

* You already built a minimum viable product

* You already got feedback on that product

* You already networked with people who would lead to the next round, growth, etc

* You already spent money on marketing

Unless you've pivoted, what is Y-Combinator (or any second accelerator) going to be able do to help you other than introducing you to another set of investors (that if you chose your first accelerator wisely you might be somewhat connected to

Other than that, there's the cap table that they explicitly mention, 3-8% of a seed stage company is less attractive if there is another 3-8% player involved. Similarly, an A round (that they help you get) is less attractive if 12-16% of the company is already in un-dilutable preferred shares.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by ProAm on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @09:45PM (#10943018)
The immediate reason is the possibility that 1 of those 5 was poor advice from the last accelerator. For instance:

* Great advice, solid mvp, good feedback, solid networking but the money you spend on marketing was too little, and done horribly. All this product needs it a good marketing plan and it abruptly begins to hockey stick and gain velocity?

I think the real reason is dilution and/or wanting an 'industry first dibs' on any potentially valuable start up. At least if they see any promise in the product.

Re:It's harder to get into YC if you’ve been through another... by geofft on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @04:23PM (#10941466)
Better for whom? Sure, YC wants more startups in general, but that's because they want a better pool of candidates to invest in, and secondarily because it legitimizes doing a startup instead of joining a big company or academia or something else. If they're at capacity, it's not particularly relevant to them if startups they can't fund manage to exist or not, as long as the prospect of doing a startup remains attractive (which doesn't seem at risk, and arguably is also at risk from too many failed startups).