Re:WhisperPush – End of Life
by exo762 on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @02:09PM
(#10940500)
This are my assumptions:
1) Google can see Alice send message via Signal
2) Google can see Bob receive message via Signal
3) Google knows that Alice is in Bob's contacts, and Bob is in Alice's contacts
Those three pieces of data should be enough. I don't see why Google can't do time correlation of those messages. Both Alice's and Bob's contact lists are very finite. It might be not obvious for single message, but for series of messages (and people chat this way) it should be very obvious who is talking to whom.
Re:WhisperPush – End of Life
by Arnt on Wednesday January 20, 2016 @03:25PM
(#10941060)
Number 1 is wrong, if I read the code correctly. The messages go from the sending phone to a whispersystems server via a protocol on top of HTTP, not via Google.
1) Google can see Alice send message via Signal
2) Google can see Bob receive message via Signal
3) Google knows that Alice is in Bob's contacts, and Bob is in Alice's contacts
Those three pieces of data should be enough. I don't see why Google can't do time correlation of those messages. Both Alice's and Bob's contact lists are very finite. It might be not obvious for single message, but for series of messages (and people chat this way) it should be very obvious who is talking to whom.