'Just one minor gripe: period instruments -- Strads/Amatis -- that have been upmod'ed, have only been modified with regard to the pitch/angle of the neck. The fingerboard is longer to facilitate the more demanding repertoire, but the neck is certainly the same length. The ribs are not shortened nor elongated in modernizing a period instrument.
Aha. Thanks for those notes.
+1 for a Chuck Traeger reference on HN. I'm also a double bassist. Agreed about instrument modifications. It's common in the bass world for a big-sounding instrument to be described as a "cannon". That doesn't speak much for having a singing tone! Maybe in the world of violins and cellos that's more important, though.
Well, there's the artillery, and then there's the cavalry, and the infantry. ;-)
Re:Why Violins Have F-Holes
by jhallenworld on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @09:51AM
(#10931081)
Oh, I have to promote my friend Noah's human powered electronic instrument, the "Electric Eel". It's no so easy to have sufficient loudness with even with electronics:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8MUgwiZULw
It uses re-purposed printer carriage with stepper motor to generate electricity. With very low latency, the pulse of power boots a synthesizer and powers the audio amp.
Instruments with a sweet tone quality, but lacking in volume, are a tough sell, and will often be modified to bring out more sound. With the exception of a few museum pieces, the Strads have all been modified over the years to make them louder, with longer necks and shorter ribs.
I suspect the cello edged out the viola da gamba because of volume.