Re:Why Violins Have F-Holes
by test1235 on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @05:22AM
(#10929752)
I wonder why guitars don't have f-holes as well?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The Gibson ES-335 has f-holes. These guitars were famously used by BB King, his own named Lucille.
When Gibson made a signature model he asked to remove the f-holes to reduce feedback:
> The most noticeable differences between the Lucille and the Gibson ES-355TD-SV on which it is based are the "Lucille" script on the headstock, the maple neck, and the lack of F-holes on the top. King requested that, to reduce feedback, there be no F-holes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucille_%28guitar%29
There's a very good song by him talking about Lucille:
The ES335 is a "semi-hollow", with a solid block of wood running from the neck to the bridge.
Archtop guitars with carved tops usually do. Flat-top acoustic guitars have a complex bracing system that would get in the way of F-holes (nylon string guitars are usually fan-braced, and steel string guitars, with more tension, are X-braced).
Some do, but the bodies of guitars (with the exception of archtops) are built differently from violins. Namely, the top and bottom of a violin are carved (the thickness ranges between 3 and 8mm), whereas the guitar has a mostly uniform thin (0.5 - 1mm) sheet of hardwood with support bars.
One of the big reasons for the different style of top is that a bowed violin string produces much stronger vibrations than a plucked guitar string, so the body of a guitar must amplify the sound much more than the body of a violin.
Archtop guitars usually do.