> it shouldn't have corners
It's not how C traditionally worked. Almost every function was knowingly made to be not "too good." I see modern programmers expect something else, what even 100 times slower languages not always give. Special cases have different possible treatments, and as soon as the exist nobody can make something that would please everyone.
Ah, I misunderstood what you meant by "doing it in your own function". Yes, wrapping the semantics will work, though doing it right and without imposing some overhead takes a bit of work.
> It's not how C traditionally worked. Almost every function was knowingly made to be not "too good." I see modern programmers expect something else, what even 100 times slower languages not always give. Special cases have different possible treatments, and as soon as the exist nobody can make something that would please everyone.
As the original post pointed out, traditionally it didn't work like this. This is how it has evolved.
I did use poor semantics though, as "undefined behaviour" has a specific meaning in C that is of course how the language was defined. What I meant was "ambiguous or unwanted behaviour". Having a clear behaviour for a particular case, even if it is just returning an error code, is fine by me.
Obviously though, there is a huge advantage to having a single layer of heap management and letting the heap management algorithm have the best insight in to how memory is being used and needed. Rolling your own realloc on top of the heap manager is as likely to create new inefficiencies as remove them.