News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by lmkg on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:29AM (#1092698)
While I generally agree with the article and disagree with the SCOTUS ruling, I do have to take exception to this statement:

> However, corporations do not exist outside of government

If you take the "corporations are most certainly not people" position (and I do), then a corporation is an agreement between a group of people with a mutual economic interest. That's not a government creation, that's a naturally arising phenomenon. You don't need any sort of government to create a corporation, although contract law would help. But I don't think it's possible to have contracts without corporations arising naturally and organically.

Am I missing something? Obviously, the US has passed a lot of laws giving corporations particular rights, responsibilities, liabilities, privileges, etc. But that doesn't mean that corporations are government creations, in the same way that citizen's rights are natural right that are recognized rather than granted.

Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by wycats on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:37AM (#1092717)
You're thinking about partnerships, which are the associations of people others are talking about (created, as you point out, via contract law).

Corporation are special entities created by governments to shield the executives from persoanl responsibility for their actions as executives. In THAT capacity, I argue that the corporation does not inherit human rights because of the shield that protects the underlying individuals for responsibility for their actions.

Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh by joubert on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:41AM (#1092727)
A corporation is established in terms of a Companies Act or the like in terms of Corporate Law (particulars depend on the jurisdiction).

A corporation is a legal person, but not a natural person. A corporation is not an agreement between a group of people. People can agree to form a corporation, but the corporation itself is not an agreement (merely the end result). For example, a corporation can act against the interests of the people who founded it.