News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by wensing on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:25AM (#1092683)
Slightly annoyed. seems wrong to me--or at least, needs an explanation, i.e. in what sense does he find it annoying. The JK Rowling analogy doesn't make it clear either.

See also: http://twitter.com/msuster/status/8502845427

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by tptacek on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:21PM (#1092811)
I was amused by the insinuation that you could "plagiarize" a business model.
Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by pg on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:35PM (#1092862)
I wasn't implying plagiarism, just that such a novel would be copying JK Rowling's premise.

Though as a matter of fact, many of them do copy chunks of our site.

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by Coax on Monday February 01, 2010 @05:21PM (#1093639)
Paul, do you fault every entrepreneur that takes a novel business model/approach and tries to improve upon it or extend it? If not, can you explain what is special about this situation?

By way of comparison, do you fault Burger King and Wendy's for taking McDonald's idea?

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by pg on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:00PM (#1093856)
Depends how much they add. Like most people, I think, I don't have a high opinion of things that could be described as knockoffs. E.g.

http://money.cnn.com/2007/10/02/technology/kopy_kat_kids.biz...

Whereas if the idea is significantly transformed, it starts to be a new idea. If someone started a YC-style operation for funding films, I'd think that was cool. In fact I've suggested it to several people.

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by Coax on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:14PM (#1093883)
Fair enough, but since there's a geographic element to startup accelerators, can't their addition merely be porting the concept to another geography?

If I visit SF and go to a great a great Hawaiian-Italian fusion restaurant (I random example), I don't think the proprietor would blame me of plagiarism if I started a Hawaiian-Italian joint in Boston.

Further, I see important differences between YC and competing accelerators. YC doesn't provide office space; TechStars and DreamIt do. I'm not sure which approach is better, but I do think it's a non-trivial difference.

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by pg on Monday February 01, 2010 @07:25PM (#1093906)
There isn't a geographic element to seed funding, though. That's the mistake they all make. People think they're starting the YC of city x, and then they discover that everyone is competing for the same national (and to some extent even international) founder pool.

You're right that office space is a distinction. It's not an innovation though. The incubators of the late 90s all did that. It was a novel move for YC to consciously discard it. So it's hard to say whether including office space was a deliberate change or a transcription error. Honestly, I'd guess the latter. The naive impulse when starting some kind of incubator is always to envision it as a space, rather than a set of relationships between people.

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by Coax on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @12:35AM (#1094389)
Point taken regarding the geographic element, your argument makes sense.

But I'm still having trouble understanding how your gripe with the other accelerators is legitimate....

In founding YC you came up with a wonderful, innovative model for birthing startups. Kudos for that. You invented a whole new paradigm of investment; that's f-ing cool. But whenever an entrepreneur comes up with an brilliant new way to do business, other entrepreneurs follow. I struggle to think of an instance where a company created a new industry and other folks didn't join. And I don't begrudge the followers; they are part of a dynamic that is central to the innovative beast that is American capitalism.

Perhaps other entrepreneurs follow because a single company can rarely support an entire industry. Perhaps they follow because they think they can do things subtly (or radically) different to improve the model. I'm not sure the reason is terribly important. The point is, inventing an industry niche does not give you a monopoly right on that niche ad infinitum.

The internet space is full of examples. Aliweb was (arguably) the first commercial search engine. I remember trying it back in 1994. At the time, it seemed damn cool. Then, soon after, I heard about a new search engine called Lycos, so I tried that. It was similar to Aliweb--I thought I slightly preferred the Lycos results, but I wasn't sure. Lycos begot Altavista; Altavista begot Dogpile; Dogpile begot Google. Each new search engine was doubtlessly dependent on its predecessors. And each new search engine had no obvious new innovation--changes were subtle, usually hidden under the hood.

I don't buy the argument that entrepreneurs should be frowned upon for entering a new industry without a radical new twist. Begrudging folks who are making subtle changes to your model seems petty. YC will, for the foreseeable future, have the name brand and network to attract better talent than all other accelerators. That--not a universal monopoly--is a proper reward for being the first mover.

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by pg on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @01:26AM (#1094458)
You're blowing this out of proportion. All I said at the event was that while I was slightly annoyed at being copied, the other YC-like organizations helped us by showing us when we mistakenly rejected people.
Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by Coax on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @01:56AM (#1094490)
Okay, fair enough, I'm probably blowing this out of proportion. That comment caught my attention because I've always sensed antagonism between YC and the other accelerators, which seems unwarranted.

I think your responses in this thread do indicate that, to some extent, you think they have unfairly stolen the YC model and their existence is unjust.

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by pg on Tuesday February 02, 2010 @02:14PM (#1095748)
Please don't put words into my mouth. All I said was that we were slightly annoyed at being copied.
Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by idlewords on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:42AM (#1092731)
It's especially baffling given that YC claims its real value is not the financial investment (which is just a stipend to keep people fed and housed), but rather the chance to rub shoulders with titans of entrepreneurship, receive sage advice from avuncular mentors, and get shopped around to VC.

None of these stated benefits are things you can just copy, so it's not clear what the griping is about.

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by byrneseyeview on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:13PM (#1092791)
If they copy the style but not the substance, it makes things worse for YC and for entrepreneurs. And they can coast on YC's good PR.
Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by idlewords on Monday February 01, 2010 @03:04PM (#1093303)
How on earth does this make sense? YC operates on a similar model to an American residential college - young people apply and attend to get access to high-quality teachers/mentors and with the expectation that participating in the program will improve their career prospects.

This model is based entirely on reputation and there is no way in which opening a competing institution makes things worse for applicants. People will apply to multiple programs and select the one they consider highest value. Institutions will compete with each other to attract the best applicants.

Re:Notes From a Conversation With Y Combinator’s Paul Graham by byrneseyeview on Monday February 01, 2010 @04:04PM (#1093454)
I'm not sure that's true. I have heard far more about the value of "college" in general than about the value of specific colleges. Companies like the University of Phoenix exist to exploit this assumption.

Schools sell education plus connections plus guidance plus a diploma; the diploma is the most tangible thing they sell, so if you just sell the diploma you can cut your costs significantly. YC invests reputation and guidance and connections and money; someone who buys the same stake in exchange for nothing but money is obviously reducing the value--and valuation--of the company they buy into.

It's the entrepreneur's decision, and there are some good seed funding programs out there (Techstars has some great portfolio companies). But in many cases, the other programs are using seed companies' generally good reputation (thanks to YC) to make less valuable investments in the same group of companies.