Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh
by ShabbyDoo on Monday February 01, 2010 @11:20AM
(#1092666)
"After all, if the corporate directors authorizing the donation didn’t expect to get some kind of benefit from the politician in return"
Of course. But, that thing in return might not be corrupt. Let's say you are a gun manufacturer and you give money to politicians who support the NRA. Corrupt? No more so than a gun owner making contributions for similar reasons. Beneficial? You bet.
Re:Corporations Cannot Have Natural Rights… Duh
by hga on Monday February 01, 2010 @12:06PM
(#1092775)
I'm pretty sure you're essentially incorrect, in that one of the things Citizens United struck down was the ban on "vote for Smith" by any non-media corporation in the 1-2 months before a Federal election (1 for a primary, 2 for a general). Wasn't it a specific ban from that provision in McCain-Feingold on their anti-Hillary movie that prompted them to file the lawsuit?
I wasn't able to quickly determine if Citizens United itself is a 527, but they are affiliated with one (http://www.opensecrets.org/527s/527cmtes2.php?ein=&cycle...).
What wasn’t legal was for another kind of corporation to use its general-treasury funds for the same purpose. The laws banning that kind of spending were based on the idea that when a for-profit corporation injects itself into the electoral process¹, it creates the appearance of political corruption if not actual corruption. After all, if the corporate directors authorizing the donation didn’t expect to get some kind of benefit from the politician in return, then they were wasting their stockholders’ money.
The majority in Citizens United acknowledged that preventing the appearance of corruption was a legitimate concern (which is why restrictions on direct donations to political parties and candidates were allowed to stand), but was so committed to the “treat corporations as people” principle that they didn’t see the point of restricting contributions from corporations.
¹I.e., corporations could run ads saying “nuclear energy is great”, but not “vote for Smith, because he supports nuclear energy”.