Re:What Working at Facebook Has Taught Me About Design Critique
by moron4hire on Monday January 18, 2016 @06:01AM
(#10923698)
This is a failure of messaging on behalf of art schools. Such classes should make it clear that certain technique is being learned, not general 'art'. If the expressed goal is to learn technique, then no student should be surprised to receive bad marks for failure to adhere to technique.
And that is schooling. This is industry. You're not here to learn the basics of your craft. You're here to perform. I don't think there is any room for junior people in a startup. Some non-producer, MBA-ran startups think they can't afford senior people. I think we can't afford the inevitable mistakes from inexperienced--however well-meaning--people.
The solution seems to be to confidently present them as rigidly plain rules and only let people in on the secret that they're breakable once they've demonstrated some degree of mastery. It's better to optimize for breaking the rules too late vs breaking the rules too early.
You see this all the time in beginner art classes. A big list of The Rules is presented up front and there's no brooking of dissention. Even if you break The Rules in the right way, you are punished because it's not yet time to break The Rules.