News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richest 1% will own more than all the rest by 2016 by Frondo on Monday January 18, 2016 @01:40AM (#10922920)
"Most capitalists would say that property rights naturally exist ..."

I would like those capitalists to show me the "property rights" molecule.

Re:Richest 1% will own more than all the rest by 2016 by Animats on Monday January 18, 2016 @02:53AM (#10923141)
The concept of "property rights without responsibility" is a Roman invention. There are alternatives. US law takes property rights more seriously than most other countries, because the US never had to get rid of feudalism. Also, one of the few lawbooks available in the early days of the US was Blackstone, who was a property rights absolutist.

In feudalism, land ownership implies the obligation to protect the inhabitants and gives them certain rights. One remnant of this is that, in Britain, you have the right to walk on the undeveloped private property of others. Also, most European countries afford renters much stronger rights than the US does.

Many nomadic societies, from the Mongols to native Americans, don't recognize the right to own real estate you're not currently using. Sharia law has the concept that land can be unowned by anyone, and can revert to that state if unused, although many Islamic countries do not do that in practice.

So no, property rights do not stem from "natural law".

Re:Richest 1% will own more than all the rest by 2016 by Houshalter on Monday January 18, 2016 @03:25AM (#10923243)
The comment you are replying to isn't disagreeing with you.

The people who believe property rights are "natural" aren't saying they aren't a human creation at all. Just that they are a human right, like other rights that are also human creations.

The justification for this is something like you own your labor and slavery is wrong, and if you use your labor to produce something, it's unfair for anyone to take it from you. Likewise it's your right to trade it for something someone else made, or do whatever. And from that you get capitalism and property rights as we know them.

However this argument doesn't cover property rights over natural resources or land. There are some arguments for that like the homesteading principle. But in general there is an argument to be made that natural resources should be publicly owned, or at least rented with the profits going to the public.

Also this argument is deontological. A consequentialist would say if violating someone's rights helps more people than it hurts, you should do it anyway. And an economist would point out that pure property rights don't work in the first place, because of market failures like public goods, common goods, information asymmetry, natural monopolies, etc. So everyone is better off if we violate them at least a little.

Re:Richest 1% will own more than all the rest by 2016 by icebraining on Tuesday January 19, 2016 @05:24PM (#10934585)
The people who believe property rights are "natural" aren't saying they aren't a human creation at all. Just that they are a human right, like other rights that are also human creations.

I don't think this is true; why would it need the "natural" moniker in such case? Natural rights proponents claim that such rights are not invented, but an universal truth, either endowed by a god (like in the US Declaration of Independence) or derived from some natural property, such as human reason.

This is contrast with people who claim that all rights are subjective creations, not an innate property of nature nor a consequence of such, and therefore are not universal.

Re:Richest 1% will own more than all the rest by 2016 by djhn on Monday January 18, 2016 @10:30AM (#10924901)
> But in general there is an argument to be made that natural resources should be publicly owned, or at least rented with the profits going to the public.

First made famous by Henry George, if anyone is interested.

An interesting use-case for cryptocurrencies/blockchain-like technology.

Re:Richest 1% will own more than all the rest by 2016 by CuriousSkeptic on Monday January 18, 2016 @12:39PM (#10925654)
Re:Richest 1% will own more than all the rest by 2016 by alienjr on Monday January 18, 2016 @05:21AM (#10923583)
It's not a "natural law", but pretty close to it. It's a social convention (behavioral equilibrium) that guarantees peace and cooperation. The greatest philosopher of property rights was David Hume and the best continuator of Hume is Anthony de Jasay: http://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/2455/231884
Re:Richest 1% will own more than all the rest by 2016 by dmgd on Monday January 18, 2016 @08:18AM (#10924188)
I would like you to show me the "sarcasm" molecule
Re:Richest 1% will own more than all the rest by 2016 by vixen99 on Monday January 18, 2016 @01:52AM (#10922967)
Ignoring the obvious that it's a 'when did you stop beating your wife?' statement, one might ask to see the 'your wealth is mine while I can bully you into handing over a sizable portion of it' molecule.