News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alphabet Shakes Up Its Robotics Division by gwern on Sunday January 17, 2016 @01:02PM (#10920230)
If you take a US perspective, perhaps, but globally, there are other bright spots. For example, after reading about iRobot's struggles to get permission for its wireless lawnmower robots, I was surprised to look into it and discover there were a fair number of lawnmower robot manufacturers for both large and small suburban scale robots which reportedly work well and are rather popular in the EU. Smaller lawns and higher labor costs speculated to be why.

(I liked the idea, but after calculating how big our property was, only the most expensive commercial lawnmower robot reached parity with our John Deere Z-track riding lawn mower's capabilities, and the payback period was implausibly long, so I'm stuck doing the mowing myself. For now.)

Re:Alphabet Shakes Up Its Robotics Division by atroyn on Sunday January 17, 2016 @01:08PM (#10920249)
I believe a lot of the autonomous mowers also require you to lay a guidewire around the boundary of your property.
Re:Alphabet Shakes Up Its Robotics Division by Qworg on Monday January 18, 2016 @12:23PM (#10925542)
There are a few that don't, but they require your lawn boundary to be fully enclosed. They bump off the barriers to know to turn around.
Re:Alphabet Shakes Up Its Robotics Division by ghaff on Sunday January 17, 2016 @01:43PM (#10920410)
I did look into this briefly, but even though I only keep a fairly modest portion of my property as a lawn, I'd still probably be looking at close to $3K, which would be about a 4-year payback relative to my lawn service--which also does some weed whacking and mows some small patches that aren't really connected to the rest of the lawn. Laying the guidewire would also be a pain.

But I can see the attraction if someone had a smallish lawn--especially if they didn't already have a lawn mower. It would be just one more task they wouldn't have to think about.

Re:Alphabet Shakes Up Its Robotics Division by Qworg on Monday January 18, 2016 @12:22PM (#10925531)
It is pretty magical having one - it is almost like the lawn never grows after it reaches a certain height. Also, the neighbors love asking questions about it.
Re:Alphabet Shakes Up Its Robotics Division by Qworg on Monday January 18, 2016 @12:21PM (#10925526)
There are also noise restrictions and lawn care differences (do you like stripes on your lawn?).

The two you mentioned (smaller lawns and higher labor costs) are the biggest drivers though.

I lead a team working on these for a major outdoor power equipment company, so I'm more than happy to chat.