Re:Alphabet Shakes Up Its Robotics Division
by Symmetry on Sunday January 17, 2016 @12:00PM
(#10920025)
I absolutely agree about CS and MechE but I my experience is that you can generally do just fine without anything cutting edge in terms of electrical engineering until you've grown a fair bit. Depending on what you're doing you might not need anything but off the shelf components like the hands we sell[1], the arms Universal Robotics sells, etc. Or if you're doing something more advanced it's probably using standard motors and ICs with a custom PCB. It's only when you're getting more advanced that you want more control of, e.g., the power system for production quality robots.
[1] Shameless plug http://www.righthandrobotics.com/
To even get off the ground, you need strong people in each of the three pillars. Additionally, you need a leader who is sufficiently knowledgeable across all three pillars. Purely from an HR/talent acquisition perspective, this is difficult logistically and financially. Uber raided NREC to accomplish this, essentially creating a second headquarters, and paid quite a bit to get the talent.
Then, you need a prototyping facility for both the ME/EEs.
To start from scratch, a very hefty investment has to be made before product development has even begun. Then you're bleeding money through the product development phase (hopefully with some pre-sales, but odds are pretty low of this). After product development, you hit manufacturing, which is extremely difficult. Bolt.io has some good reading on this.
To get to a product driving around, you've spent millions over the course of a year or two. To amortize that cost in a reasonable fashion, you've got to produce thousands of units. Fanuc took over manufacturing early on and was able to accomplish this, but for a lot of companies, the sales volume just isn't going to be there.
The DoD, with SBIRs and other long term contracts, helps fund a lot of the product development, often provides you with a paying customer, etc. The risk and amount of monetary bleeding drops significantly as soon as you partner with the DoD.