Re:Comets can't explain weird 'alien megastructure' star aft...
by PhasmaFelis on Sunday January 17, 2016 @12:16AM
(#10918391)
"A plausible model" is the key phrase. There's a huge difference between postulating that aliens might exist and produce radio broadcasts (something which we can already do, and understand very well) and that aliens might exist and be able to not only build something larger than a hundred planets, but build it in ten years. We don't even have a theory about the sort of engineering that might be required for that--it's pure speculation. And that's the problem.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Comets can't explain weird 'alien megastructure' star aft...
by cthalupa on Sunday January 17, 2016 @03:34AM
(#10918832)
>but build it in ten years.
A hundred years, actually. I made the same mistake reading the article and had to do a double take.
Re:Comets can't explain weird 'alien megastructure' star aft...
by PhasmaFelis on Sunday January 17, 2016 @04:16AM
(#10918906)
Ah, indeed. Fair point.
I think my argument still stands, though--even a hundred years for something of this scale is beyond any science we can reasonably hypothesize about. Doesn't mean we can't speculate, just that it's not terribly constructive speculation.