Re:Comets can't explain weird 'alien megastructure' star aft...
by darkmighty on Sunday January 17, 2016 @01:32AM
(#10918542)
The amount of data is so tiny and unreliable on top of that. We can't even be sure to be seeing a seashell. It's important not to ostracize who did this claim, but I too believe it will shortly turn into another example of jumping to conclusions violating Occam's Razor because the explanation excites us.
Re:Comets can't explain weird 'alien megastructure' star aft...
by FajitaNachos on Sunday January 17, 2016 @12:57AM
(#10918482)
That is a very well articulated reply.
This isn't to say that their may not be creatures [for some definition of "creature"] somewhere capable of constructing dyson spheres, but Occam's razor suggests that we focus on what is more likely. And the argument for the existence of alien technology that we cannot imagine is less well supported {because we have never encountered such a thing} than the argument for a natural process that we cannot imagine {because that is the history of scientific discovery}.
Postulating advanced technology developed by aliens based upon variation in a star's brightness is certainly no less scientific than postulating divine purpose upon finding seashell on a mountain top. It is certainly no more so either.
My money is geology over biology.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniformitarianism