News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito by dang on Saturday January 16, 2016 @05:01PM (#10917057)
Please don't do this here.

Edit: off-topic UI question—my comment was a reply to a comment that its author subsequently deleted. Is that unclear to the reader?

I've noticed that replies to comments marked [flagged] or [deleted] seem to get downvoted more, and am wondering if that's because it isn't obvious that there was a parent comment and it's no longer there.

Edit 2: Thanks for all the replies. It's clearly a problem and I've put it on our list to fix.

Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito by bouncingsoul on Saturday January 16, 2016 @11:58PM (#10918350)
Yes, the UI on mobile is unclear. Your reply to [deleted] looks like a new top-level comment: http://i.imgur.com/FodrC3R.jpg
Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito by dang on Sunday January 17, 2016 @03:45AM (#10918854)
Good point. Ok, I think I have an idea for fixing this: make the display of flagged and deleted comments look just like ordinary comments, with only the text body replaced.
Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito by jerf on Saturday January 16, 2016 @07:29PM (#10917594)
"I've noticed that replies to comments marked [flagged] or [deleted] seem to get downvoted more, and am wondering if that's because it isn't obvious that there was a parent comment and it's no longer there."

Definitely. I often find myself doing a bit of a double-take when the topic suddenly shifts, and then I find the little greyed-out "[Deleted]".

Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito by privong on Saturday January 16, 2016 @06:38PM (#10917412)
> I've noticed that replies to comments marked [flagged] or [deleted] seem to get downvoted more, and am wondering if that's because it isn't obvious that there was a parent comment and it's no longer there.

I'm pretty sure that's the case. It's not as bad when the deleted comment is at the top level, but it's anywhere farther down in the thread, it's difficult to figure out where in the hierarchy it is, in my experience. Perhaps keeping (but blanking the info in) the comment post header would better delineate the deleted comments without disrupting the visual thread?

I assume that many times, the problem instead is that replies to deleted comments are downvoted because the comments lack the context to appropriately judge the content. Other than people quoting from the comment they're replying to, I'm not sure what is a good way to deal with this.

Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito by DanBC on Saturday January 16, 2016 @07:10PM (#10917514)
It's really not clear to some people that replies to a deleted message are not replies to the message above the deleted message.

This thread contains an example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9458661

Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito by krapp on Saturday January 16, 2016 @10:06PM (#10918110)
I think it might be preferable either to disallow deleting a post that's been replied to, or to automatically mark replies to a deleted post as dead (or pruned the way "off topic" threads are.) Comments that follow a deleted post lose a lot of important context.
Re:Postmates courier beaten by SFPD while delivering burrito by dang on Saturday January 16, 2016 @11:36PM (#10918301)
Possibly, but it wouldn't solve the current question, because we'd still have the problem with replies to [flagged] and [dead] comments.