News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by mikeash on Friday January 15, 2016 @03:41PM (#10911975)
The people who receive checks from the government every month are already preselected for failure. You don't get a government check at random, you get it for being disabled, for being too old to work, for being incapable of holding down any sort of job, etc. Looking at them to see how the population at large might react to basic income is not going to be informative.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by topspin on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:16PM (#10912203)
Right, so the new check recipients will be people that were otherwise capable of sustaining themselves, as those who aren't are already accommodated. I suspect that the 'human capital' liberated by basic income will mostly find its way to level 400 World of Warcraft Death Knights and 40 000 word critiques of Breaking Bad episodes.

Should the legions of working folk try to actually use their new liberty for anything with more impact we'll ban it.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by mikeash on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:38PM (#10912310)
The idea is that "sustaining themselves" isn't necessarily all that great, and there may be a lot of people out there working minimum-wage jobs barely scraping by who might be able to do something more if they were able to move beyond that.

How many people out there have a way to improve their lives and move forward, but which requires more free time than their minimum-wage job allows? I suspect it's a lot.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by namlem on Sunday January 17, 2016 @12:09AM (#10918371)
The new check recipients who will benefit most include people who currently work, possibly at multiple jobs, but still barely earn enough to get by.
Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by phillc73 on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:25PM (#10912236)
Not in every case and not in every country.

I receive a government payment every month in the form of child support allowance. Everyone's entitled to it in the country where I live, as long as they have children.

I hold down a job and don't believe I'm pre-selected for failure because I claim the welfare allowance I'm entitled to.

Re:Finland’s basic income plan could change everything by mikeash on Friday January 15, 2016 @04:33PM (#10912269)
That's a good point, but then again you also wouldn't fit into the original point that people receiving government benefits aren't accomplishing things.