Re:Bitcoin Is Dead, Long Live Bitcoin
by snowwrestler on Friday January 15, 2016 @02:34PM
(#10911531)
Another way to look at it is, what was the goal of the Bitcoin experiment?
a. To create a new network for digital financial transactions? This seems to be what Fred Wilson is writing about, and I agree with him that the jury is still out.
b. To create a distributed currency free from government bureaucracy? Bitcoin seems well-separated from the U.S. federal government, but lately it also seems like Bitcoin has organically sprouted its own messy government bureaucracy.
> Bitcoin seems well-separated from the U.S. federal government, but lately it also seems like Bitcoin has organically sprouted its own messy government bureaucracy.
Bitcoin, nor its tokenholders, cheerleaders, etc. do not have the violence-backed power to tax. So while it may have the nasty trappings of a bureaucracy, I don't think it sinks to the level of a government bureaucracy.
That's damning with faint praise, if the best thing you can say about the Bitcoin community is that at least it hasn't monopolized its capacity for violence.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead, Long Live Bitcoin
by eli_gottlieb on Friday January 15, 2016 @02:04PM
(#10911339)
Nah. People need to learn that you simply can't build a decentralized, egalitarian system on capitalist foundations.
Has anyone built a decentralized, egalitarian system on any foundation? Call be cynical but at some point you run into human nature, and we're not fundamentally decentralising or egalitarian.
Non sense. It is not necessary for the agents in a decentralised system to be selfless in order for the system to self organise.
Edit. Drunk and offensive. But my point still stands.
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead, Long Live Bitcoin
by milkey_mouse on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:59PM
(#10913286)
This is super nitpicky but it's "Bitcoin" when referring to the currency (e.g. "the Bitcoin blockchain") and "bitcoin" when referring to an amount ("0.2 bitcoin"); it's never "BitCoin".
Re:Bitcoin Is Dead, Long Live Bitcoin
by ErikAugust on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:11PM
(#10913348)
I see, thank you.
One may frame this whole "failed versus not failed" as a power struggle between two camps:
a. Those who own a large stake in the original BitCoin - such as the developers, miners, venture capitalists, the Winklevoss Twins, etc.
and
b. Those who don't own a large stake in BitCoin currently, but wish to own a large stake in the dominant cryptocurrency. Wall Street...
When you attack BitCoin on any grounds, technological or otherwise, you are attacking those stakeholders.