Re:CAD Is a Lie: Generative Design to the Rescue
by brudgers on Friday January 15, 2016 @10:41AM
(#10909900)
It's a question of who gets to "input various things". CAD systems whether or not they incorporate heuristics or parametrics are based on:
human owner ->
human designer ->
production [possibly human] ->
artifact
However, the important high level abstraction is:
human owner -> artifact
where the "->" simply accounts for the time gap that we call "production". Getting closer to the high level abstraction is why people pay for design. For many projects having humans in the "->" is seen as a cost not a benefit...they're forced to pay a designer for time spent rounding corners and gradienting drop shadows because those things are more fun and easier than iterating.
It's also more fun than writing up vast arrays of heuristics and parametric constraints.
Computers are really really good at iterating. With machine learning, they don't require long lists of heuristics and parametric constraints. Just a lot of examples and an unimaginably large number in human terms of CPU cycles.
That's not a place AutoDesk as a publicly traded company can pivot. So in the 1990's when you were developing computational approaches, they pivoted toward a product line architecture that allows Autodesk to roll out features at regular intervals. If it had wanted to go computational, it would have doubled down on AutoLisp with macros and promoted developers. There's a business reason that full blown AutoCad developer tools require approval and that there's no AutoCad app store.
It's also more fun than writing up vast arrays of heuristics and parametric constraints.
Computers are really really good at iterating. With machine learning, they don't require long lists of heuristics and parametric constraints. Just a lot of examples and an unimaginably large number in human terms of CPU cycles.
That's not a place AutoDesk as a publicly traded company can pivot. So in the 1990's when you were developing computational approaches, they pivoted toward a product line architecture that allows Autodesk to roll out features at regular intervals. If it had wanted to go computational, it would have doubled down on AutoLisp with macros and promoted developers. There's a business reason that full blown AutoCad developer tools require approval and that there's no AutoCad app store.