I don't believe that for a second and that's even ignoring the fact you need everyone to have double the amount of anything they want to transact. A seller needs enough cash to cover the cost of all their stock and buyers will need enough money to buy everything they want twice.
What are the chances what fraudster will make money out of this?
As for your second point - this indeed will prevent large percentage of population from participation as buyers (basically everyone without savings). As for sellers - irrelevant. We are talking about markets that can benefit from security and anonymity. Higher cost of doing business is implied, but in this case its only a time-cost of money (which is all time low today).
I think 2 party escrow is a viable alternative to 3d party escrow because it should be harder to game.
I remember pointing this out about every month or so in 2014 when it seemed everyone and their dog were posting this method of escrow.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimatum_game
And we only need 51% to act punitively to ensure all fraudsters go bankrupt.
I don't have much faith in openbazaar either because they offer nothing more than a shopping cart software would get you but require a software download to use.
https://voluntary.net/bitmarkets/
Peer to peer, anonymous, two parties only, game theory and one established fact about human psychology.
Idea is following - if any of parties can't possibly gain anything from fraud in the long run, there will be no fraud. To achieve that, buyer freezes two prices of the item, seller freezes one price of the item. Money is frozen atomically, and is defrosted atomically. Money is freed only if both parties are happy. Some studies indicate that people have very strong feelings about justice IF they are dealing with strangers. This should cause strong revulsion of any unjust solution (e.g. buyer caving in just to unfreeze some of frozen money). To prevent such blackmail and other forms of psychological manipulation, both parties are anonymous by default and can't communicate using this software.
Published on MIT license.