News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by nickbauman on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:19PM (#10905590)
The folly of BitCoin is to believe that technical problems are somehow orthogonal to social problems. They never are. And never has this been more true in the history of our species than with the technology of money. Money is an artifact of the state; always has been, always will.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by snitko on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:39PM (#10905719)
>Money is an artifact of the state; always has been always will.

Nothing can be further from the truth. You don't have to go too far for the example. Cigarettes in prisons are used as money. People use all sorts of things as money. State wants to control it because it wants to collect some of the value produced by other people. That is all. Bitcoin is about not giving states these powers.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by lingben on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:22PM (#10906031)
> Cigarettes in prisons are used as money.

No. That's barter. Money has very specific characteristics. Cigarettes in prison fail these three: divisibility, durability and uniformity.

https://www.stlouisfed.org/education/economic-lowdown-podcas...

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by geomark on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:34PM (#10906103)
Cigarettes have all those properties, just somewhat imperfectly. Cartons are divisble to packs which are divisible to individual cigarettes. Cigarettes are pretty durable - if you don't get them wet and avoid breaking them they have a reasonably long shelf life. And they are pretty uniform in each division - carton, pack, cigarette. Since prisons allow prisoners to smoke cigarettes they have the cover of utility while being used as money.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by namenotrequired on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:28PM (#10906065)
The article you link yourself makes clear that those are desired, "ideal" characteristics, not the definition as you suggest.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by dnautics on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:29PM (#10906072)
I always thought that money has three characteristics: fungibility, divisibility, and verifiability (although divisibility can be relaxed for small values). Cigarettes pass two of the three, and fail only the weakest one, in a fashion that doesn't matter.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by pakled_engineer on Thursday January 14, 2016 @10:54PM (#10907061)
Slightly offtopic but they use commissary food for currency in prisons as smoking was banned years ago. http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB122290720439096481

Mackerel was chosen since it's cost was closest to $1USD, and nobody wants to eat it. It also has unique markings so they can track down theft from each other.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by logfromblammo on Friday January 15, 2016 @11:09AM (#10910134)
That's not strictly accurate. The lift-bros will eat it, as it is the cheapest source of protein. They are the ones that guarantee the marketability.

If it were truly the case that no one wanted it, it could not be used as money, as another good would quickly replace it.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by pakled_engineer on Friday January 15, 2016 @12:04PM (#10910525)
Dudes trying to get swole inside usually trade junk food for more prison chow and milk with other inmates who cant get commissary, also weight stacks were removed in most state and fed yards like California, so they fill laundry bags with water in their cells as makeshift weights when guards aren't around.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by chippy on Friday January 15, 2016 @07:13AM (#10908780)
Very interesting!

Mackerel would be worse than cigarettes as they are not divisible. It would also be a good source of Vitamin D if you were incarcerated in northern latitudes

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by nickbauman on Friday January 15, 2016 @05:35PM (#10912793)
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by rhino369 on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:33PM (#10906094)
You are of course correct. But Bitcoin is a fiat currency that exists without a state. That is rather (nearly) unprecedented.

All other decentralized money had demand other than for its currency purposes. Cigs in jail are in demand so they became a way to store value.

Bitcoin is the opposite. It has value because people are saying it's a currency. But it's monopoly money.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by hellbanner on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:41PM (#10905732)
Prisons exist because of the state.

In most countries AFAIK it is illegal to mint your own "currency" and call it as such, hence artifact of the state.

Bitcoin lets non-state actors create currency.. incidentally, those most equipped to fund the processing power, are state actors, hence artifact of the state.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by genghisjahn on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:55PM (#10905848)
7 Cities that have their own currency...

http://mentalfloss.com/article/55414/7-cities-have-their-own...

You can make your own currency all you want. You just can't make currency and pass it off as state sponsored currency without permission from the state.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by lingben on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:23PM (#10906037)
Also the much beloved and hated Canadian Tire 'money':

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Tire_money

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by nickbauman on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:32PM (#10906089)
Ever heard of a CityState?
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by ybx on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:41PM (#10905733)
> Money is an artifact of the state; always has been, always will.

This is patently false. Money has existed before states, and it has existed without states.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by nickbauman on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:50PM (#10905808)
There is almost no archeological evidence to support your claim. There is ample evidence supporting my claim.

Money (specie: often in the form of coinage but not limited to such) was invented when a warlord or monarch captures riches (mines, cities), strikes coins with his visage, uses the coins to pay his soldiers (who are otherwise awful credit risks), then demands taxes from the free peasantry, creating a market economy in the process. States create markets. Markets require states. If for no other reason than to provide protection over the transaction with the threat of coercion.

Before money existed, the free peasantry used credit. The historical evidence shows that first came credit, then came money, then came barter. The exact opposite of what Adam Smith and most economists believe.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by droffel on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:56PM (#10905860)

  The historical evidence shows that first came credit, then came money, then came barter.
Can I get a citation on this? Literally any citation that money came before barter will work.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by nickbauman on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:11PM (#10905963)
David Graeber's Debt, The First 5000 years page 49-50. He has a bunch of citations in that manuscript which are fascinating as well.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by nickbauman on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:27PM (#10906056)
It does refute it. What looked like barter on closer inspection was really credit. As in "I'll give you three chickens for that cow. I know this isn't a fair exchange but we'll mark the exchanges on this stick and later when I have something you want we'll sort it out." The stick was a record of the transaction. Sometimes the record itself was exchanged. This last step is how money emerged from credit.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by droffel on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:34PM (#10906102)
I fully agree with you about debt/credit. If I give you something without getting anything in return, that can be considered debt.

The point I'm specifically trying to come to grips with is the idea that money came before barter: considering that money is used as a token that is itself bartered for goods or services, I can't understand how money came before barter. It just doesn't make sense, using money is barter.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by pja on Friday January 15, 2016 @06:30AM (#10908576)
The idea isn’t that money came before barter - barter has always been around on the fringes of things. It’s that credit came before money & that credit tokens backed by a credible issuer turned out to be extremely useful as tokens of exchange & units of account. Hence it’s credit that evolves into money, not the things you might have bartered occasionally. Barter was for exchange with people you didn’t trust & didn’t have any kind of on-going relationship with & was therefore rare & fairly irrelevant economically. Anyone worth doing business with had some kind of credit relationship with your state anyway.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by nickbauman on Saturday January 16, 2016 @10:14PM (#10918127)
I'll answer your question: barter came after money because the barter systems that emerged came after money and they marked to a currency to measure the barter transaction. IOW, they used a virtual currency. Even Charlemagne's empire defined a virtual currency that was used hundreds of years after the empire fell apart and Charlemagne never even ever struck coin but only left behind a specification of the HRE currency.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by droffel on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:19PM (#10906013)
So I just read the pages you cited, and everything there is talking about recorded history. Barter has been in use since at least 12000BC, according to archaeological records. Your citation doesn't really refute my statement.

(For anyone who wants to follow along, the PDF can be found at https://libcom.org/files/__Debt__The_First_5_000_Years.pdf)

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:24PM (#10906041)
> Barter has been in use since at least 12000BC

The concept of debt predates the concept of barter a long time. Barter requires judging things of equal value. Debt however is easy to understand for humans regardless of ability to have the concept of possession (help me today and i help you tomorrow). I see no reason to believe that money or barter would become before debt in human development.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by droffel on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:29PM (#10906071)
I fully agree with you about debt/credit. If I give you something without getting anything in return, that can be considered debt.

The point I'm specifically trying to come to grips with is the idea that money came before barter: considering that money is used as a token that is itself bartered for goods or services, I can't understand how money came before barter. It just doesn't make sense, using money is barter.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:37PM (#10906126)
> The point I'm specifically trying to come to grips with is the idea that money came before barter

I had this discussion a few years ago and one thing that I found interesting as a thought is that barter is not something people like to do. It's generally only used if a token cannot be used because for instance the token is not stable in value. So in times of crisis people would fall back to barter as an alternative but when a stable token of exchange exists, barter does not play a role.

The first thing that develops in a new community is debt and credit but with regards to if money or barter came first there does not seem to be a lot of agreement. I personally feel that barter is quite an unnatural concept because one party will most likely always lose. I cannot imagine that it would come naturally because it's a step back from debt and credit. The only thing it would give you is the ability to trade with someone you don't trust. And that is probably when you tribe meets another tribe which I feel is something that would happen after establishing a local currency.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by groceries on Thursday January 14, 2016 @09:18PM (#10906660)
To me it seems more natural to assume that money would emerge from barter. Barter is only fair to a certain extent. As you (OP) mentioned, in bartering one party will "most likely always lose" while that isn't necessarily always true in pure black and white thinking eventually a barter system would become difficult to maintain in an economy (early or late). Now that would assume that one good or service in the exchange has more worth than the other end of the barter.

I see barter as an early, rugged form of money. Many early civilizations would trade goods such as cows or other animals in exchange for services or other goods. Technically those cows or whatever else WERE a currency. You could give someone 3 cows to help you do X, Y, Z. Replace cow with 300 gold coins and there isn't an enormous difference because each only has as much value as you allow it.

Eventually through barter you'd realize maybe you don't want to give all your cows away or perhaps people begin to realize that sure maybe now they have 3 cows since they did X, Y, Z for you but now the person they need stuff from doesn't need cows because they have 100 cows. Naturally I think currency (coin, paper money... etc) would develop from this to form a more "universal" token for barter so that it could then be more easily used by whoever receives it.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by sdenton4 on Thursday January 14, 2016 @09:59PM (#10906835)
Read graeber. He this fallacious just so story quite thoroughly. in the old times happens pretty much only between tribes, in tense circumstances, not within them. Within a tribe, purposely ambiguous debt systems tend to be used. Also, there's a strong argument that money derives from ceremonial goods used to track the exchange of human lives, in marriage, murder, our slavery.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by holdenweb on Friday January 15, 2016 @02:08AM (#10907732)
You misunderstand the concept of barter. It was actually an informal, unrecorded socially-based debt system. Read "Debt, the first 5,000 Years" for a good explanation.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by 1cyril on Thursday January 14, 2016 @09:56PM (#10906813)
Try asking what came first, law or private property (the answer is private property): the implications of that realization are far more important compared to asking whether or not barter existed before money (it did). Also, you can frame it so that debt is conceived of as a type of barter; ie - i barter a debt of equivalent value I herewith owe you in exchange for this item you're offering to give to me as a consequence of that promise.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by lmm on Friday January 15, 2016 @05:34AM (#10908390)
> Also, you can frame it so that debt is conceived of as a type of barter; ie - i barter a debt of equivalent value I herewith owe you in exchange for this item you're offering to give to me as a consequence of that promise.

The point is that "I'll give you this cow and you'll owe me one" predates "I'll give you this cow and you'll give me those chickens". To the extent that debt is a special type of barter, so is money; I think the distinction between exchanging something for a thing and exchanging something for a debt is worth making.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by swyman on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:58PM (#10905872)
Where can one read more about this?
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by natural219 on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:06PM (#10905931)
"The Ascent of Money" by Niall Ferguson is my favorite introduction to the subject. It may or may not support parent's claims.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by CyberDildonics on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:23PM (#10906034)
Before credit was gold, which throws a wrench in your beliefs.

I don't know if livestock domestication would be said to be a precursor to gold in some places.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by rodgerd on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:50PM (#10905806)
> Money is an artifact of the state

I would suggest "money is an artefact of societies" would be a better way of expressing this - people will otherwise get hung up on whether complex societies, with currencies, that don't look like modern nation-states, disprove this statement.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by slg on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:43PM (#10905754)
>The folly of BitCoin is to believe that technical problems are somehow orthogonal to social problems. They never are.

This seems to be a mistake repeated routinely throughout the tech world. You see it today's Netflix announcement about proxies. You see it with the software/media industries reliance on DRM. You see it with people trying to halt the NSA with stronger forms of encryption (or with the NSA's mass surveillance in the first place). Technology is not a cure-all and unloading an army of computer scientists on a problem isn't usually the answer.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by droffel on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:31PM (#10905662)

  Money is an artifact of the state; always has been, always will.
Money solves the "Coincidence of Wants", that is, it acts as a collectively agreed upon medium of exchange. Cowry shells, beads, feathers, and gold have all previously been used as money. I don't believe those were artifacts of the state, they were an emergent phenomenon that arose to solve a very real problem. Can you elaborate on why you believe that money always has been and always will be an artifact of the state? Because I'm really not seeing it.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by nickbauman on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:00PM (#10905895)
There are examples of it being emergent phenomenon, yes, but when you look closely at how the cowrie shells moved around, you'll see the behavior of state actors. The vast majority of the shells were stored in a single dwelling in the settlement with thick walls and often below ground. These dwellings were guarded by warrior-class members of the societies, The dwellings were connected to a single family or even just a single person: a warlord or monarch. If it walks like a duck...
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by droffel on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:08PM (#10905946)
Okay, so money follows a power law distribution (like many natural phenomena), where wealth tends to concentrate. And early people who used money needed a bank (safe/guarded place) to store it in. Your argument seems tautological, "The state uses money, therefore money is an artifact of the state". This feels like a "Wet sidewalk causes rain" situation.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by TeMPOraL on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:45PM (#10906170)
It's not tautological, it's just observing the thing a lot of people with libertarian mindset tend to forget - that state is a natural step in evolution of groups. When your society grows bigger than several dozen members, you no longer can have everyone deal with everyone else personally. You can't spontaneously coordinate larger groups of people, so a mechanism of coordination naturally arises. This mechanism pretty much always is a form of state.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by clarkmoody on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:21PM (#10906027)
> Money is an artifact of the state; always has been, always will.

  Abraham listened to Ephron, and Abraham weighed out for Ephron 
  the silver that he had named in the hearing of the Hittites, 
  four hundred shekels of silver, according to the weights current 
  among the merchants.

  Gen 23:16[1]
This silver transaction that occurred thousands of years ago was weight out based on merchant standards. Abraham was a nomad at the time, not belonging to any state. The merchants seem to be the ones who set the weight of the silver currency.

[1] https://www.blueletterbible.org/esv/gen/23/16/s_23016

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by fineIllregister on Friday January 15, 2016 @09:54AM (#10909617)
Such a claim requires the Bible be taken at face value, which is not at all certain. It very well could have been written much later than the date it supposedly occurred by political authorities to promote a specific ethno-religious order.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by polemic on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:56PM (#10905854)
Heh, the last sentence is debatable (as demonstrated). But to debate it misses the wider point of the first sentence:

> "The folly of BitCoin is to believe that technical problems are somehow orthogonal to social problems."

This. Or, to restate it, to mistake social solutions to 'money' as technical problems that need fixing.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by ivank on Thursday January 14, 2016 @06:25PM (#10905623)
What makes you think money didn't exist before the state?

http://szabo.best.vwh.net/shell.html

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by lukeschlather on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:09PM (#10905956)
What makes you think there weren't governments in the Americas guaranteeing the value of wampum prior to the invasion from Europe?

Here's an article from what remains of one such pre-colonial state detailing how wampum formed the basis of their international treaty laws: http://www.onondaganation.org/culture/wampum/

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by narrator on Thursday January 14, 2016 @08:43PM (#10906485)
>Money is an artifact of the state; always has been, always will.

Money is an artifact of the state because you have to pay taxes in the state's money. If you could pay state and local taxes in bitcoin it would be possible to use bitcoin exclusively for all transactions.

Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by CyberDildonics on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:19PM (#10906009)
Uhhh what about gold, which had been the world's currency for thousands of years up until Nixon was forced off the gold standard in the 70s.
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by SatoshiRoberts on Thursday January 14, 2016 @07:09PM (#10905948)
"Information is an artifact of the state; always has been, always will." - people before the Internet
Re:The resolution of the Bitcoin experiment by krapp on Thursday January 14, 2016 @10:04PM (#10906858)
I don't remember any "people before the internet" ever saying anything of the sort.

I am aware of plenty of people saying it about the internet now - both that information has become an artifact of the internet and that the internet has become an artifact of the state (specifically, of American cultural and political hegemony.)