Re:CAD Is a Lie: Generative Design to the Rescue
by brudgers on Thursday January 14, 2016 @08:56AM
(#10901364)
Looking at the antennae, I'm unconvinced of the claim that the second is better [though I'm not saying it isn't] because it's not clear how suitable it is as a spacecraft component. The older design looks like it would be easier to store for liftoff (in a cylinder); require a simpler deployment strategy (a linear actuator); and be less likely to poke a hole in a spacesuit during extra vehicular activity. Not that I'm claiming it was for manned spacecraft. Yet that's the sort of corner case where it makes sense to lift an omnidirectional antenna. A point and shoot parabola is the general case.
Parabolas fold and unfold well even when constructed from many parts because a lot of the parts are the same sku. The older design follows this idea by unfolding with a twist. The new antenna looks like it has more parts that are one off and looks like it depends on all of them deploying "just so" (i.e. it looks finicky). Again, the new design may actually be better. But without understanding the mission requirements, signal strength alone does not make the claim reasonable.
Parabolas fold and unfold well even when constructed from many parts because a lot of the parts are the same sku. The older design follows this idea by unfolding with a twist. The new antenna looks like it has more parts that are one off and looks like it depends on all of them deploying "just so" (i.e. it looks finicky). Again, the new design may actually be better. But without understanding the mission requirements, signal strength alone does not make the claim reasonable.