That said, I doubt physicists would have overlooked this for 100 years when they pretty consistently say you'd fall into the hole unscathed and not even know you'd passed the horizon, so I'm sure this is wrong.
There would not be Hawking radiation since the black hole has not formed.
> That said, I doubt physicists would have overlooked this for 100 years
Other people have noticed this too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternally_collapsing_object
It doesn't seem to get as much attention, I think because there is less interesting math there to do research on.
> But it IS possible to say when the even will happen from ONE of their points of view. It just might not be the same time as what the other one sees
is again demonstrating that you don't understand how time coordinates work in GR. There is not a unique way to extent an observer's proper time to a time coordinate on an entire manifold, and different extensions are incompatible. Some of those extensions, as I said, give a finite time for BH formation.
I think you're more interested in axe-grinding that teaching or learning, so I'm going to call it quits on this one.
> so it's often not possible to assign a sensible time that a particular event happens according to a clock held by an outside observer.
That's not completely accurate. The two can not assign the SAME time to some event happening - it might happen at different times for the two.
But it IS possible to say when the even will happen from ONE of their points of view. It just might not be the same time as what the other one sees.