News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does "dead" status on HackerNews means suppression of the... by trtmrt on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @04:40PM (#10897757)
Are you ok with that?

Why are pepole ok with sharing other people things, but it is not ok to share your own things?

Re:Does "dead" status on HackerNews means suppression of the... by ctdonath on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @04:47PM (#10897810)
There's a difference between "hey, I found something y'all might find interesting" vs "hey, I wrote something and I'm trying to promote it".
Re:Does "dead" status on HackerNews means suppression of the... by DanBC on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @05:06PM (#10897947)
And HN is fine with "Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

HN is not fine with

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

"Hey, I made something and I'm trying to promote it".

[repeat]

Re:Does "dead" status on HackerNews means suppression of the... by detaro on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @04:59PM (#10897901)
It is ok to share your own stuff. I mean, look at the submission history of the guy you are responding to ;) minimaxir posts tons of his own content, but it is good content, and he also participates on the site otherwise.

Also, agreed with CarolineW. Show examples.

Re:Does "dead" status on HackerNews means suppression of the... by minimaxir on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @05:14PM (#10898014)
The key word the OP mentioned is only:

Here is his example account:

https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=grisanik

All submissions are from one domain, and there are barely any comments.

Re:Does "dead" status on HackerNews means suppression of the... by detaro on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @05:22PM (#10898080)
IMHO (as a user, but one that you'll often find in the new-queue) what is critical here that

a) none of these got any user engagement (ok, some got an upvote or two and a single one actually managed to attract a comment)

b) despite this, there is a constant stream of several submissions per week

c) the user didn't comment on other articles, but just "dropped off" their content

EDIT: regarding the last edit: I don't care for Musk-news either, but if it is not spammed and not duplicate I have no reason to flag it, and apparently enough people care to upvote it. I upvote if people submit something cool they made. Others do as well, the stuff many people find cool rises. "I just added a tiny boring feature to my boring app", not so much.

Re:Does "dead" status on HackerNews means suppression of the... by ctdonath on Thursday January 14, 2016 @01:34PM (#10903343)
Looks like someone's just reflexively promoting their own blog, which contains content largely uninteresting to HN. grisanik posted 3 comments (actual participation) but submitted 30 links (nearly all self-promotion). The applicable adjective is not compelling nor interesting, but relentless.
Re:Does "dead" status on HackerNews means suppression of the... by CarolineW on Wednesday January 13, 2016 @04:42PM (#10897767)
You're not listening. Other people do share their own stuff, and don't get banned, and the items don't get flagged.

GIVE US SOME EXAMPLES!