Often it according to a simulator textbook but pilots haven't studied the text book enough so they end up being confused what mode the autopilot is on, override and crash the plane.
I think FAA even calls that as such -- "mode confusion".
Of course it could be the problem of user interface or warning and error reporting is not clear and explicit (alarm is blaring so they ... just ignore it because it has so many false positives).
http://www.amazon.com/Design-Everyday-Things-Revised-Expande...
Interesting discussion in itself.
That shorting of the runway in San Fran? Every warning worked as intended except the pilot. The prop plane that went down in Taiwan? Pilot shut down the wrong engine.
Basically if we're talking about a person being unable to actually handle the needs of modern piloting - mode confusion as it were - then I'm suspicious that they aren't very good pilots in the first place. This is where I see the correlative in cars.
Just because lane-alert and auto cruise control can help an inattentive driver stay out of a crash doesn't mean the systems can't be compromised by a poor operator. That's kind of my thought process.
That's also worth keeping in mind.
Mostly because in recent times, pilot error has been the most frequent cause of crashes, to my knowledge, in Airbus planes. Whether that's being too stupid to avoid an active combat zone and get shot down, or turning off the wrong engine and causing a prop plane to crash in a recoverable situation (granted not an Airbus).
Basically, there are pilots flying in commercial aviation today that, practically speaking, are not qualified to be stick & yoke pilots but are commercial pilots because demand far outstrips supply in some parts of the world.
I'm very doubtful that the actual autopilot has saved any lives. It's more likely to just allow captain to nap.
Are you seriously suggesting a traveler of reasonable means will look at their ticket that says AirAsia on it and think they have made the best possible deicison?
This reminds me a lot of how advanced and amazing the avionics and support systems are on Airbus planes, and why shit pilots crash them whenever anything doesn't go exactly like a simulator textbook. It's a part of the future of automotive "advancement" that I'm not optimistic about. This is certainly a personal opinion, one coming from a guy who likes to really be involved while driving and has his fair share of mistakes on his record, but I think it's worthwhile to keep in mind.