News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: by jerf on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:26PM (#1089391)
There is a near perfect correlation between people asking this question, and being unbelievably arrogant bastards too stuck up their own ass to even listen to the other side. This article does nothing to break that correlation.

This article could easily be completely discredited had they taken a moment to actually ask someone who dislikes the current health care reform why they dislike it. Considering that even large swathes of the Left currently have no great love for what has actually passed even the BBC might have been able to find such a person.

I, for one, don't give a shit how great your healthcare system is when a fundamental component of it is "Oh, and we'll break the economy on the rocky shores of immovable mandates." It doesn't matter how awesome your promises are if the economy can't sustain them. It is also perfectly reasonable to believe that the problem is that we already have too much government control, so turning it all over to the government is hardly the solution. (One question I'd ask those who still support this health care bill is, are you ready for when the Republicans control Congress and the Presidency again, and therefore control all your health coverage? It's not "if", it's "when".)

Note that arguing with me about whether we'd break the economy or whether more freedom in the market might help is besides the point. The point is that I am in fact "voting" (not yet, but I would and quite possibly will) against something I don't perceive to be in my interest. The shocker, the unthinkable thought, the terrible tragedy is not that I am willing to "vote against my interest", it is that I don't agree with you about what is in my interest.

If I seem incensed, well, I am. This is the argument of a supercilious bastard and deserves no attention, here or anywhere. People disagree with you. Deal with it. (People disagree with me too, only I don't go on about how they are stupid for "voting against their interest"....)

Re: by tsally on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:31PM (#1089399)
It is also perfectly reasonable to believe that the problem is that we already have too much government control, so turning it all over to the government is hardly the solution.

I am not aware of any health care reform legislation in the United States from any party that advocates turning it all over to the government. You actually suggest this several times in your post, so you seem to be misinformed.

Your points about the article itself are valid. Some people do ignore the fact that there are informed people on the opposite side. However, your argument would have a lot more credibility if you demonstrated understanding of the issue you are writing about.

Re: by jerf on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:45PM (#1089425)
I simplify for, well, simplicity. No 20-word summary could capture the bills. (After all, that's, what, 1 word per 200 pages of bill or so?) As summaries go, it's not entirely unreasonable either; once the bills are in place, the only things the government won't control is basically things it is choosing not to control, which on the grand scale of how much control they'd have comes in pretty close to "total control". At least in the US, that is not how our government is supposed to work.

I mean, it's not like I made an effort to hide my biases here... :)

Re: by anamax on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:48PM (#1089427)
It is also perfectly reasonable to believe that the problem is that we already have too much government control, so turning it all over to the government is hardly the solution.

> I am not aware of any health care reform legislation in the United States from any party that advocates turning it all over to the government.

"all over" is an exaggeration, but do you really want to argue that Obamacare wasn't imposing significantly more govt control than we currently have?

If you concede that point, then you're just arguing about the magnitude of what's left in private hands.

Note that using private firms for health services does not imply that those services are not under govt control. For example, the postal service uses contractors to transport mail, but that doesn't imply that the postal service isn't govt controlled.

Re: by scotch_drinker on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:32PM (#1089400)
Amen. An upvote can't possibly express my agreement. It never fails that some state in the South, this time Texas, is held up as an example of some huge population that doesn't know what's good for it leaving aside the entire history of the South (plenty of that being ugly and sad) as wanting to just be left alone.

These articles are almost always written by someone without the slightest clue what it's like to live in the South, where people want to just be left alone to handle their own problems. It's not that they don't understand their best interests. It's that they'd like to handle them themselves instead of hoping the inept government will fix things.