News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by aneesh on Saturday January 30, 2010 @03:03PM (#1089159)
Just because you suck at something doesn't mean you should automatically give up. I think it's to Microsoft's credit that they're continuing to go after search. And they're making progress with Bing, albeit very slowly. I don't see anyone else attacking Google in search.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by brandonkm on Saturday January 30, 2010 @03:53PM (#1089241)
I agree. Around 2000, I remember reading all these articles in video game magazines talking about how microsoft will never be a major player in consoles. "Microsoft is not a video game company, its not in their dna". Fast forward a bit and look at the console landscape now. 5.5 million xbox 360s were sold in the 4th quarter of 2009. The xbox can now be considered a runaway success, despite the numerous setbacks that have occured (red ring of death).

With search the landscape is a bit different, but we shouldn't be so shortsighted as to count microsoft out of the game or think that bing will never gain >50% marketshare. We could look at articles like this in 3-4 years and laugh out how off the mark it was, just like the articles in game magazines bashing the xbox in the early 2000's.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by absconditus on Saturday January 30, 2010 @04:13PM (#1089269)
Has the Xbox division been profitable over its lifetime? I realize that they are supposedly profitable now, but have their recent profits exceeded the previous losses yet?
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by ZeroGravitas on Sunday January 31, 2010 @04:46AM (#1090324)
I looked into this recently and estimates ranged from $1 to 10 Billion still to go before breaking even. About $5 billion of the variation seemed to hinge on whether the money invested into the first XBox could just be written off which I personally don't think makes much sense so you could say 6 - 10.

The part of Microsoft that makes xbox along with the zine and PC games made a profit of 0.2 Billion this year and 0.5 Billion the year before.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by jordyhoyt on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:34PM (#1089405)
Immediately profitable <> successful. They're pushing console gaming to the next level, and you can bet that their next iteration will be wildly popular. Turning a huge profit at the expense of not providing significant value is how to remove yourself from future competition.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by mattmanser on Saturday January 30, 2010 @07:10PM (#1089601)
you can bet that their next iteration will be wildly popular

No, you really can't.

Look at PS3 compared to PS2, GameCube versus nintendo 64, Saturn versus megadrive.

In fact it's practically an industry rule that you always fail after a successful generation of console! A betting man would reckon on the Xbox 3 being a flop.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by msc on Saturday January 30, 2010 @07:35PM (#1089657)
I wouldn't bet on it being a flop. In my opinion, the only unsuccessful Nintendo console was GameCube. NES, SNES, N64, Wii, all a success. PS1 was a success, so was PS2. I'm not really convinced of this industry rule you're talking about.

Wii reached an audience no console ever reached, thanks to the titles and controllers. I'm betting Project Natal will take over a big slice of that market, unless Nintendo really steps it up.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by TheSOB88 on Sunday January 31, 2010 @12:42AM (#1090086)
64 was definitely not the market leader. It may not have floundered like the Cube, but it wasn't ahead. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_video_game_consoles_...
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by aston on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:34PM (#1089407)
Cash flow positive business are destined to become profitable in the long run. But even if the division weren't cash flow positive, it'd still be a pretty good bet by Microsoft. They've successfully locked down a place in my living room that they didn't seem to have a chance at 10 years ago.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by axod on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:58PM (#1089443)
Console businesses operate in cycles. Profitable now, means nothing in 5 years. You might be completely dead in the next round of consoles.

Most xboxes are in teenage boys bedrooms not in living rooms.

The impressive part is how they've been able to convince some people that the xbox is a success.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by trezor on Sunday January 31, 2010 @06:58AM (#1090405)
I have to disagree on this one. Everyone I know with a Xbox 360 has them in their livingroom, hooked up to a big-ass HDTV.

Ofcourse you can attribute that to my age, and the fact that I don't know too many teenagers, but for the teens in my family, if they are gamers at all, what they have is a PC in their bedroom. Console-gaming is if not exclusively at least largely a social thing, and thus makes more sense to have in a room made for socializing.

While my argument isn't backed by solid data and mostly relies on my own experiences, you can't really claim yours is any better either.

As for as the Xbox 360 goes right now it is a massive success. It is one of the top three consoles in a market where there used to only be two. That's big achievement in itself.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by axod on Sunday January 31, 2010 @10:24AM (#1090542)
The numbers show wii's have massively outsold xbox+ps3. There's only one winner in the current console lineup.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by ebrenes on Tuesday February 09, 2010 @02:44PM (#1113051)
I guess the iPhone must be an abject failure then! After all, Nokia's 3300 series has sold over 200 million of those phones. So it's clear there's only one winner in the mobile phone market!

Please, if you're going to compare numbers, be aware of what you're comparing. The Wii, Xbox360 and PS3 are only similar if you're an outsider and can't realize the apple to oranges comparison that's taking place.

The Wii's major feature is that it's a family entertainment system and not a gaming console. The reason it's sold so much is because, as many others have stated, it managed to breach into new market segments. Yet when I talk with any person that dedicates a significant portion of their time to playing games (ie a gamer) they never talk about the Wii, they talk about the Modern Warfare 2, PS3 and Xbox360.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by grhino on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:55PM (#1089439)
A good part of why the XBOX 360 has done well as a gaming platform is because they were able to leverage the success of the PC as a gaming platform. Of gaming platforms, the PC has been one of the most open and easiest to develop for on the market and a lot of that has carried over to the XBOX.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by rabidgnat on Saturday January 30, 2010 @06:00PM (#1089447)
On the other hand, do big companies ever get BETTER at something?

Large companies tend to walk off their own skyscrapers. Microsoft toppled IBM with the "PC on every desk" mantra. In turn, Microsoft never won on the Internet, because they just never understood that humans network. Phone+cable+Internet companies are begging for a sassy upstart to eat their lunch when competition opens up. American car companies missed game-changing trends in consumer automobiles towards fuel efficiency.

Should Microsoft abandon search? Probably not, but they're more likely to make money if they attack markets that only have awful products. Attacking a market with strong loyalties and gold-standard type products seems like a fool's errand

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by dotcoma on Saturday January 30, 2010 @03:13PM (#1089172)
as said in the article, attacking Google in search is not going to get them anywhere. Facebook, or Apple, or Nokia (with its free GPS service on its smartphones) may steal a bit (or a lot, perhaps) of the show from Google, but I doubt Microsoft ever will.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by Niten on Saturday January 30, 2010 @04:04PM (#1089258)
But why? Really, is there any fundamental reason we should expect Google to remain perpetually on top of the search engine business?

I think the difference in quality between Google and Bing search results is negligible; at this point it's just a matter of mindshare as to whether people, on average, go to www.google.com or to www.bing.com when they want to look something up. There's no vendor lock-in propping up Google, to the extent that there is behind the Windows or iTunes monopolies. Mindshare can be altered, Microsoft just needs to figure out how to do it.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by jimbokun on Saturday January 30, 2010 @10:24PM (#1089896)
"But why? Really, is there any fundamental reason we should expect Google to remain perpetually on top of the search engine business?"

In technology, it is rare that a leader loses it's place in the market. More often, a new technology is pioneered by a new company that makes the old technology less relevant.

IBM never lost the mainframe market, but did not dominate the PC market. Google did not take over PCs, but dominates search. There are many more examples like this.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by jussij on Saturday January 30, 2010 @11:46PM (#1090015)
There was a company called AltaVista that once domminated web search.

There was also a company called Novell that pretty much invented the business of networking PC's, but where are they now?

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by lftl on Sunday January 31, 2010 @12:49AM (#1090095)
While not explicit in the parent post, I think his major point was about a leader in a mature technology field not often being replaced.

Google supplanted Altavista largely because they made huge strides in a rather new field. While it's definitely possible, it's a little hard to image someone coming along with a web search that's impressive enough to supplant Google. It's more likely that "search" would evolve into something not entirely comparable to today's search, and replace them.

Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by dotcoma on Monday February 01, 2010 @04:31AM (#1092098)
For starters, Google mints its own money via Adwords, while Microsoft still depends on Yahoo Overture, which Yahoo itself (and everybody else in the industry) acknowledged being greatly inferior to Adwords, to the point that they wanted to use Adwords to make more money out of the Long Tail of search...
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by Lazlo_Nibble on Saturday January 30, 2010 @06:41PM (#1089529)
I don't expect Google to remain perpetually on top of the search engine business. But neither do I believe that Microsoft, as we know it today, is capable of being the company that knocks them down.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by scrrr on Saturday January 30, 2010 @03:34PM (#1089202)
For quality search results theres also still http://www.ask.com and http://www.alltheweb.com . I wonder why we hear so little about those.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by wgj on Saturday January 30, 2010 @03:48PM (#1089230)
On ask.com I have to scroll the page to even reach the first organic result after the block of sponsored results. If you use it on a regular basis, don't you get tired of doing that?
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by krakensden on Saturday January 30, 2010 @03:41PM (#1089216)
I've been let down by Ask so many times over so many years (... more than 10?), I do not even think about them.
Re:Admit It, Microsoft: You Suck at the Web by jbrennan on Saturday January 30, 2010 @04:49PM (#1089317)
Don't ask.