"All they need is X" is often a misleading ideal. The further you are from your own context and culture, the less you will pick up on cues that seem small but can make all the difference in how people's behavior and environment can be changed for the better. Do people drive or walk/bus to work? Do they eat frozen food or go to the farmer's market? If they hear a bump in their house at night, is their first reaction to get their gun or 911?
A wholly strong community benefits everybody. People are friendlier. Government is more trusted. Corporations can hire talent by touting their home as a pleasant alternative to the coastal city rat races. And if it works in one place, chances are people elsewhere will seek to emulate your model, instead of having it thrust upon them.
both of the mentioned companies are totally disrupting entire industries and the world, solving people's problems in transportation and in hospitality in ways the world never saw at scale before.
I would venture to say that your advice would result in these solutions not coming into existence: with respect, I think your suggestion is not only not necessary, but doesn't work and may prevent certain solutions from coming into existence.
And they did live in the world. The world of people who rely on cabs/transport. And found it wanting, the primary motivation for starting their company. Then they learned about the industry and tried to fix it and it took years of hard work.
Airbnb hosted a nicer-looking craigslist specialized to make it really easy for people worldwide to conspire with each other to violate the terms of their leases to make a couple extra dollars while breaking a law that is hard to enforce.
And I think you'll find the founders didn't just come up with this idea out of nothing. They solved a problem that came up in their real lives.
Either way, it's entirely predictable for someone in the tech community though gross to compare these silly cash grabs to solving real cultural, social, and political problems that actually effect people in a serious way like FGM, clean drinking water in the third world, mass incarceration.
They are not developing policy solutions and they are certainly not trying to connect multiple parties who do not even agree that problems exist or may even be actively hostile to solutions because they stand to gain from said problems.
There is no chance of "eradicating" and completely solving the issue of housing for every human worldwide in the next 20 years. (It's a ridiculous thought on its face). Because it's a limited resource people are competing for, with lots and lots of overlapping interests going back thousands of years and indeed perhaps responsible for much/most of history itself.
malaria is not even within an order of magnitude of difficulty. I mean we're talking about the difference between $100 billion and $100 trillion. (to completely solve the problem for everyone forever.)
so yeah, I would plot them in the same boat (as you put it).
there's zero pressure in the opposite direction, for maintaining malaria, except the pressure from the natural world making it a somewhat tricky problem. if someone can solve it cheaply and easily they wouldn't face resistance from anyone.
Yeah. That's actually a really appealing idea. At one point, I wanted to write software to help individuals and small bookstores sell online. So what did I do? I bought a bunch of books and sold them online! I'm not saying that's why I failed... but I failed to come up with a product worth using before the market became crowded with much better products.
But... on the other hand, one thing I am still certain of... 90% of business advice and business stories are bullshit from people who don't know what they are doing. the other 10% is lies from people who do.
I just find this apparent truth to be deeply unsatisfying, that's all, and "live in that world" is a good example of business advice that sounds really good, really true, and really satisfying, but that doesn't seem to hold up when you subject it to the harsh tests of reality.
That, and I don't think I'd believe anything written by a successful businessman like Bezos. Who knows what he actually knew, who he talked to, who helped him or what his intent was at the time. now he's going to tell the best story he can, because that's what a competent businessperson would do. Because of this, I think reading advice or stories of success from proven masters is way less useful than it sounds.
The didn't change anything about taxis, they restricted the meter and administrative side of a taxi company into an app. From the town that restructures business processes into software.
Then the real issues will emerge.