News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two months after FBI debacle, Tor Project still can’t get... by sandworm101 on Monday January 11, 2016 @12:01PM (#10881599)
The intelligence community used to value Tor. Remember where it came from. Now they don't, presumably because the primary intelligence target has shifted from fixed actors like nation states and large businesses to the general public. Now those nation states and businesses are 'intelligence partners' in the fight against the 'lone wolfs' hiding within the masses. Perhaps then it is in Tor's interests to restart some rivalry between nation states.
Re:Two months after FBI debacle, Tor Project still can’t get... by rdtsc on Monday January 11, 2016 @12:22PM (#10881718)
NSA is schizophrenic in that regard. Remember that one of the things it does besides looking in everyone's underwear drawers is it also advises US govt (3 letter agencies, military) on what crypto to use. In other words it tells Uncle Sam how to lock his underwear drawers so other agencies don't peek in there.

It is always interesting to see what they say there. Because if they know, for example, one type of crypto technique or implementation is vulnerable will they still recommend it for TS classified material storage? Will they recommend for US military or diplomatic service? If they don't, it might leave that open to attack, and they are not doing their job. If they do say "don't use this combination of AES, prime numbers, or OpenSSL implementations", that also gives something away.

I wonder if people people who make these recommendations even talk to people who discover, exploit, and actively penetrate systems? Because everything is very compartmentalized, they actually might not be able to.

That is why they are probably very interested (like we saw) in somehow subverting or weakening some algorithms and implementation so they are the only ones that have a key (Dual_EC_DRBG) , or they are the only ones that potentially have a computational capacity to exploit (DES).

Re:Two months after FBI debacle, Tor Project still can’t get... by AlyssaRowan on Monday January 11, 2016 @12:49PM (#10881885)
NSA themselves have used Dual_EC_DRBG (which can be distinguished from a PRF even if you don't have the 'backdoor key': it's not just backdoored and slow, it's bad - and they know that). GCHQ behaves even worse and is at this point almost entirely out of control.

In either case, I feel information assurance and signals intelligence arms really should never have been the same agency: they are roles entirely at odds with each other and do not seem to even have their own governments' equities properly balanced, nor their recommendations always having been given in good faith. So be cautious drawing any conclusions from their advice.

Unfortunately, that is not the sort of 'reform' that either government is interested in, particularly my own. It's quite depressing, really.

Re:Two months after FBI debacle, Tor Project still can’t get... by rdtsc on Monday January 11, 2016 @01:56PM (#10882342)
> NSA themselves have used Dual_EC_DRBG

That actually makes sense because of the way it was backdoor-ed. What they did there is the golden standard of subverting and backdoor-ing a crypto algorithm: go through a standards body, backdoor-ed it by using a public-private key. They hold the private key. Encourage others to use the system as much as they can (which includes showing the world that they themselves use it).

NSA have been having dreams of key escrow forever. It seems since the 90s, that dream was further and further from reality. But they didn't completely give it up. Dual_EC_DRBG was effectively becoming that key escrow they wanted for all the system that used it and they got to keep the private key and thus have a high enough assurance others won't use their backdoor.

Whoever was in charge of that operation, was probably patting themselves on the back every morning after waking up.

Re:Two months after FBI debacle, Tor Project still can’t get... by tptacek on Monday January 11, 2016 @02:01PM (#10882388)
That's true, but lots of things are bad in ways that probably aren't exploitable, and NSA is well positioned to make judgement calls like that.
Re:Two months after FBI debacle, Tor Project still can’t get... by newman314 on Tuesday January 12, 2016 @12:40AM (#10885760)
Guess where NOBUS came from?
Re:Two months after FBI debacle, Tor Project still can’t get... by eliteraspberrie on Monday January 11, 2016 @07:06PM (#10884640)
I don't think they valued Tor specifically. They did value scientific research, which is what Tor was at the time. Like most research work, it got dropped once they had a working proof of concept. The State Department picked it up years later.