News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by scrollaway on Monday January 11, 2016 @08:20AM (#10880588)
Since their blog is coming up, asking HN:

Mondo is looking like an interesting bank. I've had my eyes on both them and Simple for a while; unfortunately, I'm not in the UK anymore nor in the US so I went with Number 26 instead. Anyone have any experience with either?

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by BillinghamJ on Monday January 11, 2016 @08:22AM (#10880592)
I live in the UK and have had a Mondo card for about a month and a half. I've been very pleased with them so far, and there is clearly a big opportunity for them to bring some innovation to traditional banking.

Any specific questions?

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by scrollaway on Monday January 11, 2016 @09:29AM (#10880910)
What's your experience been compared to traditional banks? Where do they differ the most?

Have you been disappointed by anything yet?

Have you tried them outside the UK / withdrawing euros?

How's their human support?

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by BillinghamJ on Monday January 11, 2016 @01:47PM (#10882263)
It's a little hard to compare fully as they're not a bank yet (the current card is a prepaid one which you top up via the app). Everything is a lot more simple than my traditional bank (Lloyds), they've clearly put a lot of effort into the app UX which I value. They're very responsive, both via support channels, and on the discourse forum we're all in.

There are a few issues. One is a tradeoff which can't really be fixed - all transactions are "online", allowing them to do push notifications and live fraud checks. For some card machines, particularly when using contactless, this can substantially increase the time it takes for the card machine to process the payment.

Most of the issues though seem be caused by their card issuer - rather than interfacing with the card networks directly, they currently go via a company called "GPS" (pretty sure it's http://www.globalprocessing.ae). This seems to add notable latency to some transactions, as well as causing a couple of limitations on how you start using the card. I expect all of these problems will be resolved once they issue cards directly.

I haven't used the card physically outside the UK, but I have done a number of non-GBP transactions online and they all worked fine - with good conversion rates. A number of people on the discourse forum have used it outside the UK and it looks as though they didn't have any problems.

Support is good - generally very quick responses in-app (they use Intercom), and they're very active when it comes to the extended discussion in the discourse forum. A few of the blog posts came about as a result of those discussions.

One cool thing is that almost every single screen of the app allows you to give feedback in various ways - flagging merchant details as incorrect, providing suggestions, and letting them know how urgent upcoming features are.

Having good APIs is pretty important to me also - although I haven't used them yet. The app keeps detailed logs of the internal APIs which I like to regularly dump onto my laptop for reference too!

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by germanier on Monday January 11, 2016 @09:52AM (#10881020)
I have been using Number26 as my main spending account for a few months now but wouldn't use it as my main account. There are a few things that aren't implemented yet, such as crediting cheques (I still get one or two a year) or non-SEPA transfers (though to be fair it is very expensive at banks compared to e.g. Transferwise so I wouldn't use it either way). The support is overwhelmed at the moment and over Christmas they had technical diffuculties that weren't fixed for around a week, presumbly because they had no staff on-call to do so. Also their card doesn't have a Girocard function which makes it unusable at some locations in Germany.

Unlike other banks they don't refund ATM charges. Also, according to internet forum users those tend to be a bit higher compared to other MasterCard cards for some reason. Additionally multiple users reported problems using at card at some South-East Asian POS Locations. But having a backup card is never a bad idea.

It's very convient that they immediatly deduct money from your account as soon as the charge is authorized (which makes it easier to model in my mind as it works just like real money) compared to traditional cards where it takes a few days. However that also applies to holds (e.g. from hotels). I would advise they have another card for such purposes.

Also, I wouldn't suggest keeping your money in a currency that you have no connection with simply because of the forex risk.

You might also want to take a look at Revolut https://revolut.com It's not a bank account but a very useful card with very good exchange rates.

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by scrollaway on Monday January 11, 2016 @09:57AM (#10881054)
Thanks a lot for that Revolut link, it looks like exactly what I need. Have you used it?

Regarding currency: I'm currently in the eurozone but I travel a lot. I was in sweden until recently for a year, not long enough to bother with a bank account. If I did I would actually have lost a fair bit of money, seeing how the GBP and SEK evolved in that year.

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by germanier on Monday January 11, 2016 @10:03AM (#10881091)
Yes, they offer the best rates out of any card I have ever seen. I use them for travel outside the Eurozone. They allow to keep money in EUR, USD and GBP at the same time.

Note that it's classified as electronic money under British law so much worse fund protection than a bank account if any. I wouldn't keep much money there.

They say that they will Charge fees after the first year of using it but haven't said how it will look like yet. Until now they haven't charged anything. They have planned some new features for tommorrow but I don't know what to except.

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by Symbiote on Monday January 11, 2016 @10:15AM (#10881175)
Anyone in Britain could also get a card detailed here [1].

I've been using a Halifax Clarity card for years. I've not paid any ATM or purchase charges in ~20 countries.

I now have a Revolut card, since I recently left the UK, but haven't used it yet.

[1] http://www.moneysavingexpert.com/credit-cards/travel-credit-...

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by pjc50 on Monday January 11, 2016 @11:27AM (#10881363)
Revolut: No fees and perfect interbank rates? Where do they make their money, then?
Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by germanier on Monday January 11, 2016 @04:58PM (#10883914)
Presumably they get the interchange fee (1-2% in the US and capped to 0.2% in the EU now). I suppose they operate at a loss at the moment but which business we talk about on this site doesn't?
Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by scrollaway on Monday January 11, 2016 @02:26PM (#10882609)
I got myself a Revolut account, talked to support and they say they make money as part of a deal with Mastercard, IIUC they get a % off the merchant fee.
Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by phillc73 on Monday January 11, 2016 @09:45AM (#10880984)
I tried to open a Number 26 account. After going through, and passing, their KYC process I found out the account could only be activated through their app. That is despite lack of clarity in their documentation, which I believe clearly suggest activation can be completed online through a browser.

Guess what? Their Android app can only be downloaded through Google's Play Store. I'm running CyanogenMod on my phone without gapps installed, so there was no way forward for me.

Number 26 even sent me a debit card in the post, which I couldn't activate.

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by scrollaway on Monday January 11, 2016 @09:55AM (#10881037)
Yeah, I had some similar issues with their activation process - I don't have a mobile phone number and part of their activation process requires one, so I had to borrow a phone. The idnow.eu company they work with is a nice idea (and far better than the alternatives) but I actually found they were rude and unhelpful when camera quality isn't at its best.

I think these things can be fixed though, and I'm willing to take one-time signup pains for a continuous pleasant experience. I'm still waiting on my card, looking forward to actually trying them out day to day.

Far better than HSBC in any case. What a joke. I could write a few paragraphs on how atrocious everything about them is...

Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by germanier on Monday January 11, 2016 @09:56AM (#10881049)
I also remember that they talked about such an option. To be fair they state in multiple locations that using their app is a prerequisite for having an account (I think I even remember checking such a box during signup). You also can't authorize transfers without their app. This is a deliberate choice on their side.
Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by phillc73 on Monday January 11, 2016 @12:43PM (#10881842)
Happy to install the app, just give me a direct apk and don't force me to use Google's Play Store.
Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by scrollaway on Monday January 11, 2016 @02:28PM (#10882626)
To be fair this is an exceedingly uncommon use case. I do think they should provide a standalone apk link though, you could talk to support about it.
Re:How does the wholesale foreign exchange market actually w... by phillc73 on Tuesday January 12, 2016 @05:08AM (#10886476)
I have talked to Number 26 support about it and their response, while courteous, amounted to "too bad, we don't offer a direct apk download. If you don't download the app from the Play Store, you can't verify your account."