Re:Amazon has no idea how to run an app store
by venning on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:00PM
(#10878706)
This is one of those squishy things that's hard to assess. For me, I would stop short of a title that would be unacceptable if you substituted a (private) person's name for the company/country/whatever mentioned. If it was "Susan has absolutely no idea how to ..." I would call it "over the top" myself, but I'm no moderator. The guidelines also discourage "gratuitous adjective[s]" in titles, of which "absolutely" applies.
> Do authors have no say in what they call their piece?
Absolutely. No one is asking smashcompany.com to change their title. But this isn't smashcompany.com either.
Re:Amazon has no idea how to run an app store
by derefr on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:38PM
(#10878839)
Calling something linkbait doesn't mean that that thing is factually incorrect, or even a bad title. It just means it's a superstimulus for off-topic debate. HN isn't a magazine; it's a forum. What the articles get labelled isn't about being accurate, or even evocative; it's about eliciting productive discussion.
linkbait is, at least to me, more along the lines of "you'll never believe what these developers made" and this post is nothing of the sort.