News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fraser Speirs's iPad commentary: Future Shock by jodrellblank on Friday January 29, 2010 @05:39PM (#1087743)
"While that's true, the orthogonal skills can sometimes make the real work easier. Knowing even a small amount of VBA could save you hours in Excel"

"""It is a very important lesson in rationality, that at any time, the Environment may suddenly ask you almost any question, which requires you to draw on 7 different fields of knowledge. If you missed studying a single one of them, you may suffer arbitrarily large penalties up to and including capital punishment. You can die for an answer you gave in 10 seconds, without realizing that a field of knowledge existed of which you were ignorant.

This is why there is a virtue of scholarship."""

- Good Ol' EY - http://lesswrong.com/lw/qx/timeless_identity/

This is the answer to the endless questions from my schooldays - "when are we ever going to use this?" and "will it be on the test?". If you know something you can recognise if you are in a situation where it is useful and benefit from knowing it (or choose not to use it). If you don't, you cannot recognise when you are in a situation it would be useful and will suffer arbitrary consequences from the lack of it, and won't even realise that there was a missed opportunity.

Re:Fraser Speirs's iPad commentary: Future Shock by barrkel on Friday January 29, 2010 @06:27PM (#1087851)
The corollary is that it ought then be more important to teach how to recognize what specialisms different situations require than to teach the specialisms themselves. That way, more people benefit from the powers of delegation and specialization.