News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fraser Speirs's iPad commentary: Future Shock by potatolicious on Friday January 29, 2010 @04:49PM (#1087658)
Android's open-ness has already been a thorn in its side. Right now we're seeing the splintering of the Android platform thanks to meddling by individual hardware manufacturers - consumers are getting wildly different user experiences, some worse than others, depending on who they buy an Android phone from. This is disastrous for a platform trying to gain mindshare.
Re:Fraser Speirs's iPad commentary: Future Shock by ericb on Friday January 29, 2010 @09:58PM (#1088150)
The thing to consider is who Android is meant to gain mindshare with. If it is manufacturers and service providers, the splintering isn't disastrous at all. It has achieved great market penetration because it is a ready-to-go affordable option. The customizability mainly serves to reassure skittish manufacturers who might choose differently if that wasn't a "feature."
Re:Fraser Speirs's iPad commentary: Future Shock by tvon on Saturday January 30, 2010 @10:49AM (#1088759)
Very true, and note that the the Nexus One page (http://www.google.com/phone) makes no mention of Android. If you look at the tech specs page you'll see it listed as "Android Mobile Technology Platform", that's some serious vendor-oriented naming.

I think this is a very significant point that is often misunderstood. Android isn't something that competes with the iPhone OS, it's the platform you build that competitor on.

I'm not sure that competitor exists. Not for lack of quality in devices, but for lack of the right approach. Google is saying "write apps for Android" when they need to be saying "write apps for the Nexus One (and the Nexus Two will be the same, but better)".