News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A short fable of software engineering vs. regular enginee... by leereeves on Sunday January 10, 2016 @12:52PM (#10876226)
An assembly line isn't comparable to software engineering - it's closer to a compiler.
Re:A short fable of software engineering vs. regular enginee... by krschultz on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:28PM (#10876416)
Having done both mechanical engineering & software engineering professionally, I think the assembly line is a lot closer to software operations.

If you take the same code and put it through a compiler over and over, you will get roughly the same result. If you run the same code in production day after day, some days you will get different results because of the interplay between various systems or conditions.

If you take the same design and put it through a computer controlled machine you will likely get the same results unless something breaks. If you take the same design and put it through an assembly line, you will get different results on different days because of the subtle interplay between various variations in processes.

The distinction is critical, because while you generally qualify a single operation in an assembly line much like we would run tests on a piece of software, you need to monitor an assembly line just as we need to monitor our software in production.

Re:A short fable of software engineering vs. regular enginee... by leereeves on Sunday January 10, 2016 @01:42PM (#10876495)
Yes, that is a better analogy.