News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unix Delenda Est (2015) by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 10, 2016 @10:44AM (#10875633)
To your last part - I have a problem with the current software trend that's present both in web and mobile. Everything is being dumbed down, so that it can be used from the get-go.

It is stupid. The only way you can make someone an expert of a new tool in 15 seconds is by making the tool so simple that it's completely useless. There's a reason you get a few dozen hours of training before you are allowed to drive a car around. Or fly a plane. If you want to have a simplified car UI, then one exists too - it's called a taxi.

The reason of course is the competitive market pressure. The primary interest of a company is to sell the product, not for the product to be useful. And so most of current design effort is about making software easier to sell, not about making it actually useful.

It's absurd to expect people to figure out by themselves how to use their file systems, databases or - yes - even their paper calendars. All of those are tools that require some learning to use effectively. We need to make people read manuals again, and stop expecting everything to be usable out of the box by an untrained monkey.

Re:Unix Delenda Est (2015) by toyg on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:14AM (#10875756)
>We need to make people read manuals again

If you've ever read a technical manual, you're probably in the 1% of the population. People don't even read two-lines popups, and you expect them to read complicated manuals?

What you really need is adaptive interfaces that grow in complexity as requirements expand, reliably detecting the newbie / power user / hacker progression. That's what works best. Hackers ridicule UIs that bury stuff under "Advanced" modes, but they're actually the best approach.

Doing three (or four, or five) times the work, though, is no fun for developers, so we go from "you're a dumb user, be happy with limited options" to "you're a clever user, surely you can read a 1000-pages bible before launching a command", because building multiple interfaces for the same routines is boring.

Re:Unix Delenda Est (2015) by jstimpfle on Sunday January 10, 2016 @11:30AM (#10875845)
Although it depends on what you mean by "technical" manual, 1% seems way to low.