I like your suggestion that Pinterest develop a direct businesses relationship with affiliate linkers, but I think it should be broader. If you force people to pay for the right to post affiliate links, volune will be low. It would be much better to simply add a money layer on top of the existing inspiration network.
Here's the idea: Every heavy Pinterest user is an affiliate partner
User joins the site, uses it normally. Pinterest skimlinks all their posts, creating revenue when the ser posts something high quality yhat drives purchase behavior. When the user hit a certain level of posts / views, they are invited to opt-in to a revenue sharing deal. The user gets 50% of the skinlink revenue. This incentives more sharing and creates a path for fir-profit pintresting.
The biggest challenge here is brand accounts. Brands who don't develop a direct relationship with Pinterest are skimlinked like everyone else, and basically wind up paying Pinterest for revenue-creating links to their own sites.
This would probably drive straight affiliate linking clickbaiters off the site, because they can't make as much as they would with a direct affiliate relationship with the target site. I think you'd makr up for the lost posts in higher posting rates by newly incentived power users though. It would encourage people to share actionable links, increasing the overall value of the platform.
What's awful about it?
Only on the internet does this seem to be a best practice.
(Furthermore there's nothing inherent to the experience's design that prevents it from being delivered to non logged-in users, the block is artificial, not a design constraint)
Pinterest tried skimlinking, but the some of the userbase hated that, claiming it was hurting their business.
When I used Pinterest I would not have cared if they had used skimlinks for anything I posted, but it doesn't seem to be an option I can turn on. And I want Pinterest to protect me from people posting their own affiliate links. A bunch of people post low quality content and stuff it full of affiliate links. Pinterest is worse with those people on the platform. One thing it could do is skimlink everything, and charge for people who want to use their own affiliate links. Most services provided to businesses are charged for, and allowing someone to run an affiliate marketing business on Pinterest is a service that Pinterest should charge for.
> You have a lot of lower-income, middle-America people on Pinterest than you do on other sites, and it's very female-centric. So if you're a marketer with a budget, where do you allocate it? Put it on Google or Facebook, where there are tons and tons of users where you can target very well? Or on Pinterest, which is a much smaller audience, female, lower-income, where you can't target well? It's just not as efficient."
Wait what? I see people pinning stuff for weddings (average cost of US wedding is $26k) or home redecoration (average cost of US kitchen remodeling is over $15k) so these may be lower income people, but they have something that they're saving up for and are prepared to spend considerable amounts of money on.
Carefully placed ads could be amazing for that market.
The real problems with Pinterest are the awful awful awful mobile experience which is very hostile to the user. Almost embarrassing. I don't post any links to Pinterest anywhere because of that hateful experience.