News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I will be using RISC-V in my next chip by userbinator on Sunday January 10, 2016 @02:13AM (#10874541)
However, if you're willing to consider ARM a RISC (well, almost) then there's your market success.

ARM wasn't really a pure RISC from the beginning (e.g. multicycle instructions like LDM/STM, pre/post-increment addressing modes, built-in shifts), and I'd say the market success, especially more recently, is attributable to the fact that ARM cores are becoming more x86-like.

On the other hand, MIPS is the quintessential RISC, and hit as enjoyed some success, but was never really known much for amazing performance or efficiency. I suspect RISC-V will be similar, and all the cheap Chinese tablets/phones/etc. that are currently using MIPS may switch to RISC-V instead, although many are unlicensed clones so cost may not be a factor to them.

Alpha completely dominated the performance segment for years, but they fell behind for reasons that has nothing to do with CISC vs. RISC.

Alphas relied primarily on clock frequency to achieve their performance, and were very power-hungry as a result. This is absolutely the RISC philosophy of performance via simpler designs and increasing clock frequency, which stopped being viable long ago. A 200MHz 21064 can do 0.675DMIPS/MHz and consumes 30W, or 0.0225DMIPS/MHz/W; a Pentium (P5) 100MHz has 1.88DMIPS/MHz and consumes 10W, for 0.188DMIPS/MHz/W.

Re:Why I will be using RISC-V in my next chip by FullyFunctional on Monday January 11, 2016 @02:19PM (#10882536)
This is getting off-topic, but ARMs success had nothing to do with RISC vs. CISC. It was that _Alpha_ engineers took their skill to the ARM ISA (which at the time had only very weak implementations). They created StrongARM which made people sit up and take notice. Intel ironically inherited the technology and continued developing it under the XScale name. So, yes, Intel in part created their own ARM problem.

I feel I have to repeat again that none of this had to do with RISC vs. CISC. It had to do with implementation and market muscle.

"Alphas relied primarily on clock frequency to achieve their performance, and were very power-hungry as a result"

So was the P4 and it failed, but Intel had enough capital to take a power efficiency clue from Transmeta and turn the ship 180 degrees.

What killed the Alpha was three things: delays in getting the new models out, the cost of staying in this game, and of course, the arrival of Itanic.

EDIT: An aside: the 64-bit extension of ARM is a completely new and different ISA called AArch64 which incidentally is a lot more RISC-like than the original ARM. IOW, it looks like the ARM designers disagree with you.