Also, it seems the paperwork and entities involved would get messy. The "employees" still own the car and need to expense/depreciate it, right?
It doesn't have the same dynamic as the payroll tax, but it's misleading because the other point applies: the more benefits you buy for workers, the less (direct) cash you have to offer to entice them to do the work. Like with health insurance, a mandate for it would just mean Uber would lower time/mileage rates. In effect, this is the same as forcing drivers to use their cash earnings to buy unemployment insurance, which may be a worse use of the money.
>Also, it seems the paperwork and entities involved would get messy. The "employees" still own the car and need to expense/depreciate it, right?
Huh? They're already doing that as contractors. And Uber is now at the scale where (relatively) fixed paperwork costs aren't that big a deal.
(The bit about "not having to pay employer tax share for contractors" is a red herring; the sum of the employee and employer tax shares is the same, and economic incidence is -- per a well known result -- unaffected by who the tax authority assesses the taxes on.)
It would be a little less profitable (because of the parties' supply/demand curves, and hence why they oppose it) but it doesn't break the core business model.