News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The End of the Taxi Era by SilasX on Saturday January 09, 2016 @01:32PM (#10872270)
I don't think that's true. All it would mean is that Uber would lower cash payout rates and provide some employee benefits, in effect forcing drivers to take some of their complemsation as employee benefits.

(The bit about "not having to pay employer tax share for contractors" is a red herring; the sum of the employee and employer tax shares is the same, and economic incidence is -- per a well known result -- unaffected by who the tax authority assesses the taxes on.)

It would be a little less profitable (because of the parties' supply/demand curves, and hence why they oppose it) but it doesn't break the core business model.

Re:The End of the Taxi Era by nopzor on Saturday January 09, 2016 @02:57PM (#10872608)
I assume that people who say "not having to pay employer tax share for contractors" they mean things like unemployment insurance, and other employer-components of "payroll tax"? Is that still a red herring?

Also, it seems the paperwork and entities involved would get messy. The "employees" still own the car and need to expense/depreciate it, right?

Re:The End of the Taxi Era by SilasX on Saturday January 09, 2016 @04:02PM (#10872874)
>I assume that people who say "not having to pay employer tax share for contractors" they mean things like unemployment insurance, and other employer-components of "payroll tax"? Is that still a red herring?

It doesn't have the same dynamic as the payroll tax, but it's misleading because the other point applies: the more benefits you buy for workers, the less (direct) cash you have to offer to entice them to do the work. Like with health insurance, a mandate for it would just mean Uber would lower time/mileage rates. In effect, this is the same as forcing drivers to use their cash earnings to buy unemployment insurance, which may be a worse use of the money.

>Also, it seems the paperwork and entities involved would get messy. The "employees" still own the car and need to expense/depreciate it, right?

Huh? They're already doing that as contractors. And Uber is now at the scale where (relatively) fixed paperwork costs aren't that big a deal.