News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Gates pledges $10bn for a 'decade of vaccine' by ComputerGuru on Friday January 29, 2010 @12:45PM (#1086998)
I know you didn't mean to come off so harsh, but what you're saying sounds so very selfish.

Who's to decide that person x is to live while person y is to die? Everyone deserves a chance to be the one that lives. Yes, sure, with the famine and the wars and the political problems in these regions it is an interesting thought that perhaps more people will lead to more problems, but it is so very cruel to say that maybe it's best that people die to disease and sickness rather than be given a chance to prove themselves.

Re:Bill Gates pledges $10bn for a 'decade of vaccine' by sp332 on Friday January 29, 2010 @01:05PM (#1087057)
...it is so very cruel to say that maybe it's best that people die to disease and sickness rather than be given a chance to prove themselves.

mberning didn't say that. Just because dying of dysentery is bad, doesn't mean that throwing money at the problem in isolation is necessarily better.

Re:Bill Gates pledges $10bn for a 'decade of vaccine' by mberning on Friday January 29, 2010 @12:55PM (#1087023)
Yes, you are right, I do believe everybody deserves a chance and we shouldn't allow people succumb to disease as a means of population control.

It seems like there are a lot of other pieces to the puzzle that you need to figure out before you introduce a population swell, otherwise you could be creating a generational problem. Save a few million lives today and at the expense of future misery for rather more people.

On the other hand, it could work out great and alleviate a lot of the problems that are holding people back in the first place.

Re:Bill Gates pledges $10bn for a 'decade of vaccine' by shaddi on Friday January 29, 2010 @01:04PM (#1087053)
This is a good point. In fact, the most effective form of population control turns out to be girl's education (both sexual education and otherwise), which reduces the birth rate. High burdens of disease prevent girl's education from happening, especially in regions where there already exists an education imbalance based on gender. Girl's education has a variety of positive non-population control effects as well (consider that without educating women, 1/2 of a nation's population will not be as productive as they would be otherwise).

So the current situation is high birth rates with high death rates, which keeps population in a grim equilibrium while the rest of society's resources are spent trying to keep as many people alive as possible rather than engaged in productive development. Reducing the burden of disease is a necessary first step in freeing up these resources to be used in other ways, like girl's education, which will help to alleviate many of the problems of a "sudden" population boom that you mention.