The companies that get into YC are often speculative in their ideas. Maybe it is devaluing the idea over the execution. Maybe it is the belief that getting in early to a growing trend is more valuable than reinventing an existing idea.
Regardless, the result is great teams of founders who think the key to success is a crazy idea. Sometimes crazy ideas work (AirBnB was kinda nuts at the time) but there seems to be a heavy weight in companies funded towards those types of investments versus the ZenPayrolls. Which tends to attract the same.
* They were Switchboard Labs at the time, doing something totally different.
Nevertheless, the fact that yc invested pre-pivot only reinforces my point, as ZP wouldn't even exist had YC not taken a chance on the team and then helped them find a more promising idea.
I see your point, that the team is the most important part and YC invested in that. My feeling is that YC can be more effective at funding those types of ideas and teams. That the hit rate can be higher by focusing on a different class of idea. Perhaps that means more pivots or different ideas accepted at the start. I'll try to flesh this out more.
P.S. Unrelated, but thank you for sharing your thoughts. I appreciate it
There's always room to improve, but it's likely they are making fewer mistakes than you think.
AirBnb was almost dead when they got into YC. Nobody would fund them, and Nate had moved to Boston to get a real job.
http://www.paulgraham.com/airbnb.html
And that's just one public example. (Chris Sacca also turned them down.)
Empirically it would be shocking if they were the only 2 investors who had the opportunity to invest but didn't.
Airbnb is actually still nuts. They probably aren't even to the half-way point in terms of where they need to be to be actually mainstream.
I think it's great that you believe in what you are doing versus what other "all-star" teams may choose to do but your comment is equally frustrating, IMO.
When you talk with them, they never say (or say without knowing it) that their biggest problem is financial transparency. Or that customers want to buy but want an anonymous currency. Or that they need to switch between many different currencies. BTC has always felt like a solution in search of a problem. The blockchain is wonderful technology as well, but that's not the hardest part of most startups.
This makes sense to me more on the scale of a single company. Put together a great team and focus them on a long-term problem. Their year-over-year drive and passion will outlast the rollercoaster of starting a company, leading to a much better shot of those huge returns.
Rather than going all in on the flavor-of-the-week, I agree with the focus on radical improvements to existing markets. It's far more likely—which does not mean less impactful—that we can fix known problems than fix as-yet-unknown problems.
You can keep a low hit-rate and focus on giant returns by playing the lottery, but fortunes are built on compound interest and diversified portfolios.
Reducing the number of failures does not mean getting rid of the big winners. It could mean focusing on large existing industries over speculative, pie-in-the-sky trends.
Think about ZenPayroll (disclaimer: early employee there, biased.) Product-focused payroll is not sexy, but the impact is massive and a tremendous business opportunity. We're now building software for local governments. Not sexy, huge market, huge impact on humans, clear path to single, double, and home-run.
My biggest frustration with looking for founding teams chasing these speculative bets is the sheer waste of human talent. I don't want to see another all-star team waste their time on bitcoin and food-delivery.
There are real, serious problems with the same upside but whose "failure" scenario may be a $25m business.