The mental cost of task switching probably takes a larger toll than Alt-Tab-ing.
> She practically kicked me out of bed and told me to find my 6-LCD X-Mas gift.
;-) Probably because you kept whinning and talking about it and she got tired of it.
> I've always been anti-laptops because come on, how can you even compare a 3 or 6-LCD setup to a laptop with a tiny screen, tiny keyboard, and crappy batteries.
I am also in general anti-laptops but for a different reason -- keyboards. As long as I can fit 2 80 column code windows in my emacs I can work fine, but not if the keyboard is crappy. That is why I spent a little extra and got a thinkpad -- it has one of the best keyboards and an integrated trackpoint (nipple) mouse. Between that and using emacs I don't have to lift my hands from the keyboard at all.
Now I still use a laptop as my main machine (Dell D830), but I've got some extra monitors (and other hardware as well). They're handy for glance-over peripheral stuff, but I work best with things right in front of me (mostly vim, bash, and a Web browser).
This topic got me wondering if alt-tabbing for window-switching, or ctrl-Fn'ing to a different desktop, was all that much of a distraction, or a worse interrupting, than moving my head and adjusting my focus. I just don't see it. Switching apps or desktops via the keyboard is no more of a "context switch" than moving my head and attention to a different device. Maybe even less so. Finger memory FTW.
Mostly I think I just adapt to what I have when I have it. Additional screen space, while nice, doesn't mean that much of a productivity gain.
What makes the biggest difference to productivity is how distracted/distractable I am. With no room for IM or IRC and such, they simply get turned off or moved to a desktop out of view. With the extra screen, I'm tempted to keep them running off to the side.
It seems a lot like closet space. They more you have, the more stuff you find to put in it. You acclimate.
They call it the "clitoris" and the name fits pretty well IMO. Last time I noted this I got downmodded something rotten.
Recently I had a change in direction and stopped taking my laptops out unless it was for a specific trip. Instead, I enjoy myself when I'm out. If I get a cool idea, I have a little pocket notebook to write the idea in. (I might start taking a netbook along someday, but at present the netbook that I have - EEE900 - is just too underpowered for the work I'm doing. So it's a web-browsing box only, which I don't need for work. I think I need to get rid of that thing altogether.)
So instead, I focused on improving the home environment. I got a monitor(HP2009M 20") a few weeks ago and added a USB keyboard and trackball and figured that I would have a dual-monitor setup with that and the laptop monitor. Except that it hasn't worked out that way; Win7 makes it pretty easy to tile things two or three across if necessary with the Win+(Arrow key) shortcuts and the 20" has ample resolution for that. And my work style has transitioned towards "one thing at a time, no distractions." I haven't used an IM client in months. IRC rarely. So the laptop screen sits empty most of the time, like right now, and I have unused space on the main monitor too! (That would change quickly if I were to go back to having stuff I check impulsively every two seconds again, but it's probably better not to...)
The main improvement to what I have, I guess, would simply be a more powerful box, possibly with multiple drives so I can keep clean, separate OS installs without even having to dig into partitioning...which leads me towards thinking about a desktop again...
I'm not sure about this. Context switching is not a good idea. Imagine that you are in the middle of your project and a new IM message appear in your first monitor.
I had been talking on and on for years about getting a 6-LCD setup and I'd even predetermined what I'd do with each LCD in a 3x2 layout (top1: IM/Chat, 2: Graphics Editor, 3: Putty/Shell, bottom 4: FTP/Explorer, 5: Text Editor, 6: Browsers). My techie friends laughed at me but at a resolution of about 2048x1152/LCD, I would have ample resolution for just about everything and I wouldn't have to alt-tab at all. My productivity in web-dev would absolutely sky-rocket. And since could rig my own stand instead of buying a $600 one, I could get my dream-setup for about $1500. I had built my workstation in 2007 to easily handle 6 DVI ports when the time was right. Now all I needed was an excuse to splurge.
Last month, two of my Dell 19" died, leaving me with just one monitor. My wife joked that I needed new monitors because she didn't wanna be married to some one-LCD guy. She practically kicked me out of bed and told me to find my 6-LCD X-Mas gift. I spent three hours surfing Newegg, Dell Outlet etc. and finally found my dream setup. Right before I clicked 'Place Order' I yelled out "Honey if I click this button, I'm never leaving my computer room." I don't think she heard me but I clearly did and for some weird reason I didn't like it. I cleared my cart and started looking for a laptop instead.
I've always been anti-laptops because come on, how can you even compare a 3 or 6-LCD setup to a laptop with a tiny screen, tiny keyboard, and crappy batteries. However, something went off in my head at that point and I realized I didn't want my perfect 6-LCD setup even though it was right there in front of me. I have wanted 6-LCDs every single day for the past decade - ever since I started making web-apps. But it was when I yelled that I don't want to leave my room that I realized that I actually do want to leave my room. Now I take my laptop with me everywhere I go and program whenever/wherever I want to. It's a very big change for me and my productivity has definitely taken a hit. However, my desire to code has risen and that is important. Who cares if I'm capable of being highly productive if I don't feel like it most of the time? I guess the take-home lesson here is that it is not the specs but the environment and experience the setup fosters. I still might buy my 6-LCDs someday, if I ever have a crazy do-or-die startup idea, but for now, I'm just happier with a laptop.