News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:14 Megapixel, Six Monitor Ubuntu Karmic Setup by chime on Friday January 29, 2010 @10:54AM (#1086695)
In 2001, I bought my first LCD, a 19" Princeton Graphics monitor for $1200. In 2004, I bought two Dell 19" for $600 each to replace the original LCD. In 2007, three Dell 19" LCDs for $400 each to replace the two Dells. Now, I can buy six 23" LCDs for approx. $200 each for a total cost of about $1200. It's funny how the number of monitors continues to increase while the total nominal investment remains constant.

I had been talking on and on for years about getting a 6-LCD setup and I'd even predetermined what I'd do with each LCD in a 3x2 layout (top1: IM/Chat, 2: Graphics Editor, 3: Putty/Shell, bottom 4: FTP/Explorer, 5: Text Editor, 6: Browsers). My techie friends laughed at me but at a resolution of about 2048x1152/LCD, I would have ample resolution for just about everything and I wouldn't have to alt-tab at all. My productivity in web-dev would absolutely sky-rocket. And since could rig my own stand instead of buying a $600 one, I could get my dream-setup for about $1500. I had built my workstation in 2007 to easily handle 6 DVI ports when the time was right. Now all I needed was an excuse to splurge.

Last month, two of my Dell 19" died, leaving me with just one monitor. My wife joked that I needed new monitors because she didn't wanna be married to some one-LCD guy. She practically kicked me out of bed and told me to find my 6-LCD X-Mas gift. I spent three hours surfing Newegg, Dell Outlet etc. and finally found my dream setup. Right before I clicked 'Place Order' I yelled out "Honey if I click this button, I'm never leaving my computer room." I don't think she heard me but I clearly did and for some weird reason I didn't like it. I cleared my cart and started looking for a laptop instead.

I've always been anti-laptops because come on, how can you even compare a 3 or 6-LCD setup to a laptop with a tiny screen, tiny keyboard, and crappy batteries. However, something went off in my head at that point and I realized I didn't want my perfect 6-LCD setup even though it was right there in front of me. I have wanted 6-LCDs every single day for the past decade - ever since I started making web-apps. But it was when I yelled that I don't want to leave my room that I realized that I actually do want to leave my room. Now I take my laptop with me everywhere I go and program whenever/wherever I want to. It's a very big change for me and my productivity has definitely taken a hit. However, my desire to code has risen and that is important. Who cares if I'm capable of being highly productive if I don't feel like it most of the time? I guess the take-home lesson here is that it is not the specs but the environment and experience the setup fosters. I still might buy my 6-LCDs someday, if I ever have a crazy do-or-die startup idea, but for now, I'm just happier with a laptop.

Re:14 Megapixel, Six Monitor Ubuntu Karmic Setup by rdtsc on Friday January 29, 2010 @02:05PM (#1087244)
> (top1: IM/Chat, 2: Graphics Editor, 3: Putty/Shell, bottom 4: FTP/Explorer, 5: Text Editor, 6: Browsers).

The mental cost of task switching probably takes a larger toll than Alt-Tab-ing.

> She practically kicked me out of bed and told me to find my 6-LCD X-Mas gift.

;-) Probably because you kept whinning and talking about it and she got tired of it.

> I've always been anti-laptops because come on, how can you even compare a 3 or 6-LCD setup to a laptop with a tiny screen, tiny keyboard, and crappy batteries.

I am also in general anti-laptops but for a different reason -- keyboards. As long as I can fit 2 80 column code windows in my emacs I can work fine, but not if the keyboard is crappy. That is why I spent a little extra and got a thinkpad -- it has one of the best keyboards and an integrated trackpoint (nipple) mouse. Between that and using emacs I don't have to lift my hands from the keyboard at all.

Re:14 Megapixel, Six Monitor Ubuntu Karmic Setup by jamesbritt on Saturday January 30, 2010 @01:45AM (#1088356)
I worked for a few months using only a Toshiba Portege 3440 (or something). 12" screen with 1920x1200 rez. Had the trackpoint. Sweet machine, great for travel.

Now I still use a laptop as my main machine (Dell D830), but I've got some extra monitors (and other hardware as well). They're handy for glance-over peripheral stuff, but I work best with things right in front of me (mostly vim, bash, and a Web browser).

This topic got me wondering if alt-tabbing for window-switching, or ctrl-Fn'ing to a different desktop, was all that much of a distraction, or a worse interrupting, than moving my head and adjusting my focus. I just don't see it. Switching apps or desktops via the keyboard is no more of a "context switch" than moving my head and attention to a different device. Maybe even less so. Finger memory FTW.

Mostly I think I just adapt to what I have when I have it. Additional screen space, while nice, doesn't mean that much of a productivity gain.

What makes the biggest difference to productivity is how distracted/distractable I am. With no room for IM or IRC and such, they simply get turned off or moved to a desktop out of view. With the extra screen, I'm tempted to keep them running off to the side.

It seems a lot like closet space. They more you have, the more stuff you find to put in it. You acclimate.

Re:14 Megapixel, Six Monitor Ubuntu Karmic Setup by pbhjpbhj on Saturday January 30, 2010 @08:04AM (#1088600)
>an integrated trackpoint (nipple) mouse

They call it the "clitoris" and the name fits pretty well IMO. Last time I noted this I got downmodded something rotten.

Re:14 Megapixel, Six Monitor Ubuntu Karmic Setup by chipsy on Friday January 29, 2010 @07:22PM (#1087949)
I've been going laptops-only for several years now. They're nice in a lot of ways - small form factor, simplicity - but also a bit frustrating because I inevitably take them out somewhere, get them a little bit bashed up, and eventually start seeing intermittent video issues, DVD drive failure, etc. That is, the "wear+tear" factor is going to be higher simply because I allow it to be.

Recently I had a change in direction and stopped taking my laptops out unless it was for a specific trip. Instead, I enjoy myself when I'm out. If I get a cool idea, I have a little pocket notebook to write the idea in. (I might start taking a netbook along someday, but at present the netbook that I have - EEE900 - is just too underpowered for the work I'm doing. So it's a web-browsing box only, which I don't need for work. I think I need to get rid of that thing altogether.)

So instead, I focused on improving the home environment. I got a monitor(HP2009M 20") a few weeks ago and added a USB keyboard and trackball and figured that I would have a dual-monitor setup with that and the laptop monitor. Except that it hasn't worked out that way; Win7 makes it pretty easy to tile things two or three across if necessary with the Win+(Arrow key) shortcuts and the 20" has ample resolution for that. And my work style has transitioned towards "one thing at a time, no distractions." I haven't used an IM client in months. IRC rarely. So the laptop screen sits empty most of the time, like right now, and I have unused space on the main monitor too! (That would change quickly if I were to go back to having stuff I check impulsively every two seconds again, but it's probably better not to...)

The main improvement to what I have, I guess, would simply be a more powerful box, possibly with multiple drives so I can keep clean, separate OS installs without even having to dig into partitioning...which leads me towards thinking about a desktop again...

Re:14 Megapixel, Six Monitor Ubuntu Karmic Setup by oscardelben on Friday January 29, 2010 @12:13PM (#1086908)
> My productivity in web-dev would absolutely sky-rocket.

I'm not sure about this. Context switching is not a good idea. Imagine that you are in the middle of your project and a new IM message appear in your first monitor.

Re:14 Megapixel, Six Monitor Ubuntu Karmic Setup by chime on Friday January 29, 2010 @12:25PM (#1086946)
IM is pretty much for working in teams. If it's on a different LCD it would be easier to ignore too.
Re:14 Megapixel, Six Monitor Ubuntu Karmic Setup by TerminalDummy on Friday January 29, 2010 @02:15PM (#1087276)
Why not have the best of both worlds ? A nice home setup and a laptop as well. Laptops are nice but I don't think they will ever be able to rival a true desktop experience. Their keyboards are cramped and their screens often get tiring to look at. I've got one and another on the way but I still use my desktop when I'm at home 90% of the time . Not to mention with a 3-LCD setup I do actually see that boost in productivity that you spoke of.
Re:14 Megapixel, Six Monitor Ubuntu Karmic Setup by pbiggar on Saturday January 30, 2010 @05:14AM (#1088487)
> I would have ample resolution for just about everything and I wouldn't have to alt-tab at all.

You sound like a man in desperate need of virtual desktops.